‘They can survive just fine’: Bernie Sanders says income over $1bn should be taxed at 100%

Authored by theguardian.com and submitted by Eliza_neff
image for ‘They can survive just fine’: Bernie Sanders says income over $1bn should be taxed at 100%

The US government should confiscate 100% of any money that Americans make above $999m, the leftwing independent senator Bernie Sanders said late last week.

Sanders expressed that belief in an exchange on Friday evening with the host of Who’s Talking to Chris Wallace? on HBO Max.

Wallace had asked Sanders about the general assertion in his book It’s OK to Be Angry About Capitalism that billionaires should not exist.

“Are you basically saying that once you get to $999m that the government should confiscate all the rest?” Wallace asked the US senator from Vermont, who is an independent but caucuses with Democrats and has helped them attain their current slim majority in the upper congressional chamber.

“Yeah,” Sanders replied. “You may disagree with me but, fine, I think people can make it on $999m. I think that they can survive just fine.”

Wallace had earlier mentioned how the late Sam Walton could make the giant retail chain Walmart the largest single private employer in the US thanks to his family’s net worth of about $225bn. Sanders countered that Walmart in many cases pays starvation wages to its 1.2 million employees despite how rich the Waltons are.

“Many of their workers are on Medicaid or food stamps,” Sanders said, referring to forms of government assistance for which low-income Americans can qualify. “In other words, taxpayers are subsidizing the wealthiest family in the country. Do I think that’s right? No, I don’t.”

Nonetheless, Sanders said his comments on the matter weren’t a personal attack against the Waltons or other billionaires.

“It is an attack upon a system,” Sanders said. “You can have a vibrant economy without [a few] people owning more wealth than the bottom half of American society” combined.

He added that if he were in charge: “If you make a whole lot of money, you’re going to pay a whole lot of money.”

Sanders’s remarks are unlikely to ingratiate him with proponents of the US political right who already dismiss him as a communist. But they have never been a part of his base of supporters.

skip past newsletter promotion Sign up to The Guardian Headlines US Free newsletter For US readers, we offer a regional edition of our daily email, delivering the most important headlines every morning Privacy Notice: Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see our Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see our Privacy Policy . We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. after newsletter promotion

The 81-year-old has held one of Vermont’s US Senate seats since 2007. He had spent the previous 16 years representing the state in the US House of Representatives, helping him become the longest-serving independent in American congressional history.

Sanders, who has previously run unsuccessfully to become a Democratic presidential candidate, published It’s OK to Be Angry About Capitalism in February. In it, he notes that one-tenth of 1% of the US population owns 90% of the nation’s wealth, among other things.

He also argues that “unfettered capitalism … destroys anything that gets in its way in the pursuit of profits”, including the environment, democracy and human rights.

On Friday, Sanders told Wallace that he believes “people who work hard and create businesses should be rich”, but the concept of some being billionaires offended him deeply when a half-million Americans are homeless and 85 million of them cannot afford to buy health insurance.

boringhistoryfan on May 2nd, 2023 at 09:59 UTC »

They take a quote and give it a spin "taxed at 100%" that he didn't say at all. This is just blatant misinformation.

“Are you basically saying that once you get to $999m that the government should confiscate all the rest?” Matthews asked the US senator from Vermont, who is an independent but caucuses with Democrats and has helped them attain their current slim majority in the upper congressional chamber.

“Yeah,” Sanders replied. “You may disagree with me but, fine, I think people can make it on $999m. I think that they can survive just fine.”

He's not proposed a tax or even called for it. He's simply giving a shrug level response to an absurd claim made by the interviewer. Literally nobody on earth declares an actual income of a billion. All of this is in various assets. Bernie simply shrugged at an asinine, and likely loaded comment, and everyone's whipping themselves up into "Bernie wants a 100% tax"

He literally hasn't said that. His policy position in that interview, ie the position he advances, is a return to tax rates as under Eisenhower. Which is totally reasonable.

EyeLikeTheStonk on May 2nd, 2023 at 06:12 UTC »

To better understand:

$1 billion = 1,000 million.

Provided you become a billionaire at age 40 and died at age 90, here's what you could do with $1 billion, invested with a 2% return rate :

You could spend $75,000 a day, each day, 7 days a week for 50 years. You could buy a $525,000 Hyper car (Lamborghini, Ferrari) every week for 50 years. (2,600 cars) You could buy a $2,275,000 house every month for 50 years (600 houses) You could buy a new $27 million Challenger 350 private jet every year for 50 years. (50 jets)

If you cannot live with $1 billion... You have a problem...

arlondiluthel on May 2nd, 2023 at 05:40 UTC »

I think there are shockingly few individuals that actually make more than $1B/year, and anyone who's even close to having a net worth over $1B can do a lot of screwy things to keep themselves from "officially" crossing that threshold. The tax code is designed in a way that the rich can take advantage of systems, loopholes, whatever, while the poor have no means to pay less.