Dolphins’ psychological trauma after being hunted for marine parks revealed in new research

Dolphins are being left traumatised by cruel hunting practices used to supply the international trade in marine mammals for water parks, scientists have warned.

As intelligent animals that many experts believe are capable of complex thoughts and even grief, conservationists say there is no place for the routine capture and slaughter of dolphins in Japan.

In the drive hunts that take place near the town of Taiji, dolphins and small whales are herded from the open sea using a fleet of fishing vessels.

We’ll tell you what’s true. You can form your own view. From 15p €0.18 $0.18 USD 0.27 a day, more exclusives, analysis and extras.

Hunters create a wall of underwater noise by banging hammers and rods, disorientating the creatures and driving them into a small cove.

There, some of the dolphins are slaughtered for their meat, while others are captured alive to be sold to dolphinariums in Japan, China and a handful of other nations.

Shape Created with Sketch. Tragic photos show beached whales Show all 15 left Created with Sketch. right Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Tragic photos show beached whales 1/15 A dead sperm whale lies on Hunstanton beach in Norfolk on February 5 2016 AFP/Getty 2/15 Volunteers pour buckets of water over the 80 remaining live pilot whales found stranded on remote Ocean Beach on New Zealand's southern-most Stewart island, January 8 2003 AFP/Getty 3/15 Contractors clear away the body of one of the dead 48ft sperm whales that were washed-up on a beach near Gibraltar Point in Skegness, Lincolnshire in 2016 PA 4/15 People pass by a beached whale at the Pointe de la Torche, near Brest in France on November 29 2011 AFP/Getty 5/15 A woman touches the tail of a large whale carcass on Wattamola Beach at the Royal National Park in Sydney on September 25 2018 AFP/Getty 6/15 Beached humpback whale in California, 2015 AFP/Getty 7/15 Dead long fin pilot whales at Hamelin Bay on Australia's west coast on March 23 2009 AFP/Getty 8/15 A 36ft sperm whale lies dead on the beach at Sutton Bridge, in The Wash, off the Lincolnshire coast, where it became stranded in 2004 PA 9/15 A female fin whale opens its mouth as it lies stranded and alive on the beach at Carlyon Bay, Cornwall on August 13 2012 Getty 10/15 The lower jaw of a dead sperm whale that stranded itself on a beach in Hunstanton, Norfolk on February 5, 2016 Getty 11/15 One of the five sperm whales that were found washed ashore on beaches near Skegness, Lincolnshire over the weekend on January 25 2016 Getty 12/15 Employees at work to skin the remains of a beached 60ft whale on January 25 2013 AFP/Getty 13/15 Two long-finned pilot whales are stranded on a beach in the northern French city of Calais on November 2 2015 AFP/Getty 14/15 A sperm whale lies dead after becoming stranded on a beach in Hunstanton, Norfolk on February 5 2016 Getty 15/15 Crowds gather as a sperm whale lies dead after becoming stranded on a beach in Hunstanton, Norfolk on February 5 2016 Getty 1/15 A dead sperm whale lies on Hunstanton beach in Norfolk on February 5 2016 AFP/Getty 2/15 Volunteers pour buckets of water over the 80 remaining live pilot whales found stranded on remote Ocean Beach on New Zealand's southern-most Stewart island, January 8 2003 AFP/Getty 3/15 Contractors clear away the body of one of the dead 48ft sperm whales that were washed-up on a beach near Gibraltar Point in Skegness, Lincolnshire in 2016 PA 4/15 People pass by a beached whale at the Pointe de la Torche, near Brest in France on November 29 2011 AFP/Getty 5/15 A woman touches the tail of a large whale carcass on Wattamola Beach at the Royal National Park in Sydney on September 25 2018 AFP/Getty 6/15 Beached humpback whale in California, 2015 AFP/Getty 7/15 Dead long fin pilot whales at Hamelin Bay on Australia's west coast on March 23 2009 AFP/Getty 8/15 A 36ft sperm whale lies dead on the beach at Sutton Bridge, in The Wash, off the Lincolnshire coast, where it became stranded in 2004 PA 9/15 A female fin whale opens its mouth as it lies stranded and alive on the beach at Carlyon Bay, Cornwall on August 13 2012 Getty 10/15 The lower jaw of a dead sperm whale that stranded itself on a beach in Hunstanton, Norfolk on February 5, 2016 Getty 11/15 One of the five sperm whales that were found washed ashore on beaches near Skegness, Lincolnshire over the weekend on January 25 2016 Getty 12/15 Employees at work to skin the remains of a beached 60ft whale on January 25 2013 AFP/Getty 13/15 Two long-finned pilot whales are stranded on a beach in the northern French city of Calais on November 2 2015 AFP/Getty 14/15 A sperm whale lies dead after becoming stranded on a beach in Hunstanton, Norfolk on February 5 2016 Getty 15/15 Crowds gather as a sperm whale lies dead after becoming stranded on a beach in Hunstanton, Norfolk on February 5 2016 Getty

In a new study, a team of psychologists, veterinarians and conservationists lay out the evidence based on years of behavioural and physiological data for widespread trauma that goes beyond the killing of dolphins.

“The stress and acute trauma resulting from being chased at sea, driven towards shore, corralled by speed boats and then violently handled during the selection process, is profoundly inhumane,” said study leader Courtney Vail, from environmental consultancy the Lightkeepers Foundation.

Even the individuals that are released following the hunt or evade capture are likely to be profoundly influenced in ways that could throw groups of these highly social creatures into disarray.

Additional trauma comes as mothers are separated from calves, and any young dolphins left without a parent after the hunt are unlikely to survive.

“Survivors that witness the capture and killing of close pod mates are likely to be caused significant stress,” said co-author Philippa Brakes, a research fellow at charity Whale and Dolphin Conservation.

The Taiji drive hunts achieved infamy after the success of the 2009 Oscar-winning documentary The Cove, which included footage of dolphins being slaughtered with knives and spears.

Despite the international outcry that followed the film’s release, the hunts have continued.

Official figures show that in the hunting season that ended in February, nearly 600 dolphins have already been killed, and nearly 250 taken into captivity.

Dr Diana Reiss, who initially tipped the filmmakers behind The Cove off about the practice, has been researching dolphin intelligence and self-awareness for over 40 years.

The new paper published in the Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, which she co-authored, supports the idea that drive hunts, which are also practised in the Faroe Islands, are inherently inhumane.

“This practice flies in the face of all welfare practices that are done in other countries,” said Dr Reiss, who is based at Hunter College.

According to Ms Brakes, the discussion about the trauma inflicted on the many more animals that are not captured and killed has so far largely been missing from the policy debate.

She said she hoped their findings would help end the capture of these animals for use in aquaria by drive hunting – a practice that has already faced criticism from many zoo organisations.

Last month campaigners from Australia and Japan launched the first legal challenge against the Taiji dolphin hunt, arguing they contradict the nation’s own animal cruelty laws.

It comes after Japan faced international condemnation at the end of 2018 for announcing its intention to withdraw from the International Whaling Commission and resume hunting in its waters.

“If you see what they are doing, it doesn’t take a PhD to say ‘this is inhumane’,” said Dr Reiss.

“The arguments by the fishermen and the government are that it is humane, and I don’t know how they can say that.”

The Independent has contacted the Japanese Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries for comment.