Detroit has third year of balanced budgets; state oversight could end soon

Authored by freep.com and submitted by greentroit

Aerial view of the skyline of downtown Detroit. (Photo: ROMAIN BLANQUART)

It's too late to impress Amazon — but here's good news for Detroit's image.

And city residents can't hate it.

Detroit's latest financial report shows the city finished its third consecutive year with a balanced budget. Topping that, Detroit ended with a surplus in the general fund budget of $53.8 million, according to a summary released Thursday.

That means that the city is poised to have its last layer of state oversight lifted, perhaps as soon as March.

"The law says if we have three years of consecutive balanced budgets, the state oversight ends," said John Hill, the city's chief financial officer.

More: Duggan, Weaver, Fouts among Michigan mayors going to White House

More: Duggan, Snyder headline groundbreaking for Detroit's new tallest skyscraper

Although the state-appointed Financial Review Commission turned some powers back to the city in recent years, the group still approves all city contracts over $750,000 and those of two or more years in duration, Hill said.

Officials said the city's turn-around has been rapid and thorough-going since Detroit hit bottom, financially speaking, less than five years ago. It was July 2013 when Detroit became mired in the nation's biggest municipal bankruptcy.

If the Financial Review Commission does vote to waive its oversight, it won't go away. Instead, the group would continue to vote each year for the next decade whether to resume oversight if the city somehow stumbles back into red ink, said John Naglick, the city's finance director — and a former financial director of Pontiac, during its time under three state-appointed emergency managers.

Detroit's consistently strong numbers are accompanied by efficiencies inside city hall, officials said. The city's latest annual financial report — for the fiscal year 2017, which ended June 30 — was signed, sealed and delivered to Mayor Mike Duggan four months earlier than the previous year's report, according to the city's summary. Duggan is a member of the state's Financial Review Commission, along with state Treasurer Nick Khoury, Detroit City Council President Brenda Jones and others appointed by Gov. Rick Snyder.

Duggan issued this statement Thursday: "Balancing our third consecutive budget shows that this administration, in close partnership with City Council, is able to effectively manage the city's finances (and) helps set the stage for the end of active state financial oversight."

The latest good news "provides a base ahead of the city's budget developmental process" to lay out detailed projected budgets for the next four years, through fiscal year 2022, officials said in a conference call Thursday.

The practice of budgeting for years in advance was pioneered by Oakland County in the 1980s, then became widely adopted by municipal and county budget setters over the last two decades, according to national experts on public financing.

Video: Detroiters talk about the city exiting bankruptcy in 2014

CLOSE Detroiters talk about the city and Judge Rhodes' approval of the City's bankruptcy exit plan on November 7. Eric Seals, Detroit Free Press

Read or Share this story: http://on.freep.com/2FBzmXp

Kcl308 on February 2nd, 2018 at 18:21 UTC »

They must have put Ben Wyatt and Chris Trager on the job.

JeffTXD on February 2nd, 2018 at 14:53 UTC »

And now they have Blake Griffin.

Laminar_flo on February 2nd, 2018 at 14:46 UTC »

This is great for the city and all, but it needs a little bit of context. First off, the mayor(s)/administrators offices deserve a huge kudos for pulling off a bankruptcy (BK) of this size - it was the largest municipal BK in US history by a factor of 5x (it was a $20B BK).

Looking at the BK itself, there were a ton of factors, but the two biggest elements were debt and revenues. First, nearly half of Detroit simply wasn't paying its property taxes, which is fucking insane in the US - that's some 3rd world shit. Property taxes are the top way (most) municipalities fund themselves. If 50% aren't paying, well, you are probably going to BK. Secondly, the city simply said "guess what?! Jokes on you! We aren't paying our debts anymore!" Detroit's creditors were paid between $0.14-$0.75 on the dollar, with a mean of about $0.20 on the dollar. PLus, Detroit can't borrow anymore (for the most part), so they don't have a choice when it comes to running a balanced budget.

In plain english, it would be if like an average redditor suddenly saw their salary double (Detroit started collecting from the 50% of people who weren't paying taxes), and decided to kill all their debts for $0.20 on the dollar (goodbye student loans and credit card debt!) - I'm pretty sure 99.9% of redditors would see their financial situation improve dramatically. Mix in the fact that nobody will loan to you, and (guess what?!), your monthly budget is gonna balance....