Strengthening Causal Estimates for Links Between Spanking and Children’s Externalizing Behavior ProblemsPsychological Science

Establishing causal links when experiments are not feasible is an important challenge for psychology researchers. The question of whether parents’ spanking causes children’s externalizing behavior problems poses such a challenge because randomized experiments of spanking are unethical, and correlational studies cannot rule out potential selection factors. This study used propensity score matching based on the lifetime prevalence and recent incidence of spanking in a large and nationally representative sample ( N = 12,112) as well as lagged dependent variables to get as close to causal estimates outside an experiment as possible. Whether children were spanked at the age of 5 years predicted increases in externalizing behavior problems by ages 6 and 8, even after the groups based on spanking prevalence or incidence were matched on a range of sociodemographic, family, and cultural characteristics and children’s initial behavior problems. These statistically rigorous methods yield the conclusion that spanking predicts a deterioration of children’s externalizing behavior over time.

Abidin R. R. , Abidin R. R. ( 1990 ). Parenting Stress Index (PSI). Charlottesville, VA : Pediatric Psychology Press . Google Scholar

Bandura A. ( 1977 ). Social learning theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ : Prentice Hall . Google Scholar

Baumrind D. , Larzelere R. E. , Cowan P. A. ( 2002 ). Ordinary physical punishment: Is it harmful? Comment on Gershoff (2002) . Psychological Bulletin, 128, 580 – 589 . doi: 10.1037/0033-2909.128.4.580 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Berlin L. J. , Ispa J. M. , Fine M. A. , Malone P. S. , Brooks-Gunn J. , Brady-Smith C. , , . . . Bai Y. ( 2009 ). Correlates and consequences of spanking and verbal punishment for low-income White, African American, and Mexican American toddlers . Child Development, 80, 1403 – 1420 . doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.2009.01341.x Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Bickel G. , Nord M. , Price C. , Hamilton W. L. , Cook J. T. ( 2000 ). Guide to measuring household food security. Alexandria, VA : U.S. Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service . Google Scholar

Bowlby J. ( 1980 ). Attachment and loss: Vol. 3. Loss, sadness and depression . New York, NY : Basic Books . Google Scholar

Caldwell B. M. , Bradley R. H. ( 1984 ). Home Observation for Measurement of the Environment. Little Rock : University of Arkansas at Little Rock . Google Scholar

Choe D. E. , Olson S. L. , Sameroff A. J. ( 2013 ). The interplay of externalizing problems and physical and inductive discipline during childhood . Developmental Psychology, 49, 2029 – 2039 . doi: 10.1037/a0032054 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Eisner M. P. , Malti T. ( 2015 ). Aggressive and violent behavior . In Lamb M. E. (Vol. Ed.) & Lerner R. M. (Series Ed.), Handbook of child psychology and developmental science: Vol. 3. Socioemotional processes ( 7th ed. , pp. 794 – 841 ). New York, NY : Wiley . Google Scholar Crossref

Ferguson C. J. ( 2013 ). Spanking, corporal punishment and negative long-term outcomes: A meta-analytic review of longitudinal studies . Clinical Psychology Review, 33, 196 – 208 . doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2012.11.002 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Funk M. J. , Westreich D. , Wiesen C. , Stürmer T. , Brookhart M. A. , Davidian M. ( 2011 ). Doubly robust estimation of causal effects . American Journal of Epidemiology, 173, 761 – 767 . doi: 10.1093/aje/kwq439 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Gershoff E. T. ( 2002 ). Corporal punishment by parents and associated child behaviors and experiences: A meta-analytic and theoretical review . Psychological Bulletin, 128, 539 – 579 . doi: 10.1037/0033-2909.128.4.539 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Gershoff E. T. , Grogan-Kaylor A. ( 2016 ). Corporal punishment by parents and its consequences for children: Old controversies and new meta-analyses . Journal of Family Psychology, 30, 453 – 469 . doi: 10.1037/fam0000191 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Gershoff E. T. , Lansford J. E. , Sexton H. R. , Davis-Kean P. , Sameroff A. J. ( 2012 ). Longitudinal links between spanking and children’s externalizing behaviors in a national sample of White, Black, Hispanic, and Asian American families . Child Development, 83, 838 – 843 . doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.2011.01732.x Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Gresham F. M. , Elliott S. N. ( 1990 ). Social Skills Rating System manual. Circle Pines, MN : American Guidance Service . Google Scholar

Grogan-Kaylor A. ( 2005 ). Relationship of corporal punishment and antisocial behavior by neighborhood . Archives of Pediatric & Adolescent Medicine, 159, 938 – 942 . doi: 10.1001/archpedi.159.10.938 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Grolnick W. S. , Deci E. L. , Ryan R. M. ( 1997 ). Internalization within the family: The self-determination theory perspective . In Grusec J. E. , Kuczynski L. (Eds.), Parenting and children’s internalization of values: A handbook of contemporary theory (pp. 135 – 161 ). New York, NY : Wiley . Google Scholar

Lansford J. E. , Deater-Deckard K. , Bornstein M. H. , Putnick D. L. , Bradley R. H. ( 2014 ). Attitudes justifying domestic violence predict endorsement of corporal punishment and physical and psychological aggression towards children: A study in 25 low- and middle-income countries . Journal of Pediatrics, 164, 1208 – 1213 . doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2013.11.060 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Larzelere R. E. , Gunnoe M. L. , Roberts M. W. , Ferguson C. J. ( 2017 ). Children and parents deserve better parental discipline research: Critiquing the evidence for exclusively “positive” parenting . Marriage & Family Review, 53, 24 – 35 . doi: 10.1080/01494929.2016.1145613 Google Scholar Crossref

Larzelere R. E. , Kuhn B. R. , Johnson B. ( 2004 ). The intervention selection bias: An underrecognized confound in intervention research . Psychological Bulletin, 130, 289 – 303 . doi: 10.1037/0033-2909.130.2.289 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Lepper M. R. ( 1983 ). Social control processes and the internalization of social values: An attributional perspective . In Higgins E. T. , Ruble D. N. , Hartup W. W. (Eds.), Social cognition and social development (pp. 294 – 330 ). New York, NY : Cambridge University Press . Google Scholar

Maguire-Jack K. , Gromoske A. N. , Berger L. M. ( 2012 ). Spanking and child development during the first 5 years of life . Child Development, 83, 1960 – 1977 . doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.2012.01820.x Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Miller P. , Henry D. , Votruba-Drzal E. ( 2016 ). Strengthening causal inference in developmental research . Child Development Perspectives, 10, 275 – 280 . doi: 10.1111/cdep.12202 Google Scholar Crossref

Mulvaney M. K. , Mebert C. J. ( 2007 ). Parental corporal punishment predicts behavior problems in early childhood . Journal of Family Psychology, 21, 389 – 397 . doi: 10.1037/0893-3200.21.3.389 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Early Child Care Research Network, & Duncan G. J. ( 2003 ). Modeling the impacts of child care quality on children’s preschool cognitive development . Child Development, 74, 1454 – 1475 . doi: 10.1111/1467-8624.00617 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Olson S. L. , Lopez-Duran N. , Lunkenheimer E. S. , Chang H. , Sameroff A. J. ( 2011 ). Individual differences in the development of early peer aggression: Integrating contributions of self-regulation, theory of mind, and parenting . Development and Psychopathology, 23, 253 – 266 . doi: 10.1017/S0954579410000775 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Radloff L. S. ( 1977 ). The CES-D scale: A self-report depression scale for research in the general population . Applied Psychological Measurement, 1, 385 – 401 . doi: 10.1177/014662167700100306 Google Scholar Link

Rosenbaum P. R. , Rubin D. B. ( 1983 ). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects . Biometrika, 70, 41 – 55 . doi: 10.1093/biomet/70.1.41 Google Scholar Crossref

Russa M. B. , Rodriguez C. M. , Silvia P. J. ( 2014 ). Frustration influences impact of history and disciplinary attitudes on physical discipline decision making . Aggressive Behavior, 40, 1 – 11 . doi: 10.1002/ab.21500 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Shadish W. R. , Cook T. D. , Campbell D. T. ( 2001 ). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. New York, NY : Houghton Mifflin . Google Scholar

Sobel M. E. ( 1982 ). Asymptotic confidence intervals for indirect effects in structural equation models . Sociological Methodology, 13, 290 – 312 . doi: 10.2307/270723 Google Scholar Crossref

StataCorp. ( 2015 ). Stata Statistical Software: Release 14 [Computer software]. College Station, TX : Author. Google Scholar

Straus M. A. ( 1990 ). The Conflict Tactics Scales and its critics: An evaluation and new data on validity and reliability . In Straus M. A. , Gelles R. J. (Eds.), Physical violence in American families: Risk factors and adaptations to violence in 8,145 families (pp. 49 – 73 ). New Brunswick, NJ : Transaction Publishing . Google Scholar

Stuart E. A. ( 2010 ). Matching methods for causal inference: A review and a look forward . Statistical Science, 25, 1 – 21 . doi: 10.1214/09-STS313 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline

Taylor C. A. , Hamvas L. , Rice J. , Newman D. L. , DeJong W. ( 2011 ). Perceived social norms, expectations, and attitudes toward corporal punishment among an urban community sample of parents . Journal of Urban Health, 88, 254 – 269 . doi: 10.1007/s11524-011-9548-7 Google Scholar Crossref, Medline