Half of 8th grade class from New Jersey refuses to pose with House Speaker Paul Ryan

Authored by abc7ny.com and submitted by easilygreat
image for Half of 8th grade class from New Jersey refuses to pose with House Speaker Paul Ryan

A group of middle school students from New Jersey caused quite a flap, after half of them refused to take a picture with Republican House Speaker Paul Ryan.It happened Thursday during a field trip to Washington.Reaction from the students' parents are as politically divided as the country."It's not just a picture," said Matthew Malespina, a student.Matthew says he couldn't go through with it.It didn't matter that Paul Ryan is the Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, or that he is third in-line to the presidency.When he and his classmates from South Orange Middle School had the chance to take a picture with the speaker. Matthew watched from the parking lot with 100 of his fellow students."It's being associated with a person who puts his party before his country," Matthew said.The students were on a field trip to Washington. Matthew found out the night before."I'm just not going to do it," Matthew texted his mother."Say you would rather not," she wrote back. And Matthew agreed."The point was, 'I don't want to be associated with him, and his policies and what he stands for,'" said Elissa Malespina, Matthew's mother.Other parents see it differently. One of them disagreeing on social media that the students should respect the office of the Speaker of the House, even if they disagree with the man who holds that office.The students, from a progressive, upper middle class community, were evenly-split. 100 others posed with Ryan. Miles Handelman was one of them."I thought it would be very cool just seeing the man who is the third most powerful man in our country. It would be cool, even if you disagree with him," Handelman said.Students say the speaker left entirely unaware of the eighth grade dissidents watching from a distance.

ThisMonthIAm on May 28th, 2017 at 13:52 UTC »

One of them disagreeing on social media that the students should respect the office of the Speaker of the House, even if they disagree with the man who holds that office.

This was a concept we learned in the military. It was necessary in the military to observe and respect the chain-of-command. In war, in a tense situation, there may not be time to put all orders in context or make sure everyone understands the situation. A superior office has to be able to just give orders and expect them to be obeyed with alacrity.

These children are not in the military. This concept of respecting the office is not necessary for civilians. In fact, it is antithetical to our duties as citizens. We are specifically responsible for who occupies which office. It is our duty to observe them, judge them and replace them if we don't like them. A blind respect for authority is a strength in the military but weakens a democracy.

cardboardguru13 on May 28th, 2017 at 11:45 UTC »

the students should respect the office of the Speaker of the House

Some might say the current speaker of the House doesn't respect his own office.

Tb1969 on May 28th, 2017 at 11:27 UTC »

Ryan was uaware of hundred students standing nearby? The students getting the picture weren't talking? I'm fairly certain he was aware then or at least must be by now.