State schools should not teach religious doctrine, says Muslim community leader
Education offered to students in state schools should be secular and no religion doctrine should be supplied, Ahmadiyya Muslim Community president Laiq Ahmed Atif said today.
Mr Atif was reacting to the request made by Imam Mohammed El Sadi that Muslim students be taught Islam at secondary school following the announcement that the Mariam Al Batool School would be shutting its doors for older students.
“I have been following the issue and I believe that religion and state should always remain separate. State schools should be providing secular education to all students equally,” Mr Atif said.
If the state wants to give lessons on religion, then this should be a comparative study of all religions and not as doctrine. - Ahmadiyya president
The Ahmadiyya is an Islamist reformist movement founded in the 19th century and encapsulates a few million people in more than 200 countries.
READ: Debate on Islam in schools heats up
According to Mr Atif the students would then go their respective religious leaders for education, suggesting Imams and priests.
“If the state wants to give lessons on religion, then this should be a comparative study of all religions and not as doctrine but some basic points on the different religions,” Mr Atif said.
Ahmadiyya Muslim Community president Laiq Ahmed Atif.
He insisted that the state schools should serve to bring the students together and not to further separate.
The debate on whether Islam should be taught in schools has been fuelled with different views on the matter.
Education Minister Evarist Bartolo said he had no problem with the suggestion, provided that teaching was accredited by the education authorities and recognised in the same way as other subjects.
Archbishop Charles Scicluna also reacted, saying Church schools should be able to teach Islam to Muslim students if this was feasible.
He insisted that while Church schools would remain Catholic these had to also respect the religious freedom of others.
Otterfan on April 3rd, 2017 at 03:00 UTC »
Some context here before this gets lost in the traditional stupid reddit muddle about Islam.
This guy (and the article) is from Malta, where Roman Catholicism is the state religion and is taught in state schools. From the Maltese Constitution:
Some people in Malta feel that the traditional Catholic education in schools should be augmented with education about Islam (not education in Islam). The subject of the article believes that neither Islam nor Catholicism should be taught in state schools.
pcmsia07 on April 2nd, 2017 at 22:36 UTC »
This guy is an Ahmadiyya, which most muslims do not consider as muslims. Saudi Arabia even bans them from Mecca since only muslims are allowed to enter Mecca.
ionised on April 2nd, 2017 at 22:00 UTC »
To be fair, though most other Muslim communities consider the community this guy belongs to as heretics. So it's unlikely to really be have much of an effect.
Edit: I no can grammar, sometimes.