Quebec's education minister has formalized a promise to ban prayer rooms and other religious practices in the province's public schools.
Bernard Drainville issued a directive late Wednesday saying schools must ensure that none of their spaces are used "in fact and in appearance, for the purposes of religious practices such as open prayers or other similar practices."
"Schools are places or learning and not places of worship," Drainville wrote on his Twitter account, where he published a copy of his order.
No requests for accommodation will be heard, the government added.
The directive came after Drainville said earlier this month that he had learned of at least two Montreal-area schools permitting students to gather for prayer. He said the concept of prayer rooms runs counter to Quebec's policy of official secularism. The province's secularism law, known as Bill 21, already prohibits many public servants, including teachers, from wearing religious symbols on the job.
The directive notes that the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms recognizes freedom of religion but also the fundamental importance of secularism.
It also notes that "according to the principle of freedom of conscience, a student has a right to be protected from all direct or indirect pressure aimed at exposing him or influencing him so that he conforms to a religious practice."
Drainville has said that he can't ban prayer altogether and that students who want to pray should do so discreetly and silently.
The directive applies to public schools, vocational schools and adult education centres, but not to private schools or Indigenous school boards.
It will be up to school service centres — which replaced school boards — to ensure "appropriate corrective measures" are taken in cases of non-compliance.
The ban has been denounced by Muslim groups, which have said they would keep a close eye on how it's implemented to ensure rights aren't violated.
Afin de préserver le caractère laïque de l’école publique, j’émets aujourd’hui la directive concernant les pratiques religieuses dans nos écoles publiques.
Les écoles sont des lieux d’apprentissage et non des lieux de culte.
Voici la directive ⬇️⬇️ pic.twitter.com/X9yUgmZiKH — Bernard Drainville (@BDrainvilleQc) April 19, 2023
This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 20, 2023.
serb2212 on April 20th, 2023 at 16:54 UTC »
Quebec fought so hard to get the Catholic out of schools. No point in letting anything else in.
znk on April 20th, 2023 at 14:45 UTC »
It's amazing that Québec went from a place where pretty much every school was administered by the church to this in like 60 years or so.
sakurablossoms_5 on April 20th, 2023 at 13:13 UTC »
Can anyone clarify this?
Is it just banning the school from actively participating in setting up religious environments ex. prayer rooms, setting aside additional time to pray for students, or does it also include the school actively stopping the students from engaging in personal religious practices?
As an example, there are students who will sit at their desk and prior to eating their lunch engage in personal prayer. Or students may ask to step outside the classroom to engage in prayer during lunch. Are teachers and admin responsible to stop this?
The former is understandable. The latter is getting uncomfortably close to policing students themselves instead of just the school and workers of the school. At what point does Quebec reach France levels and disallows students wearing hijabs to attend public schools (https://www.thenationalnews.com/world/europe/2022/08/04/france-breached-womans-rights-over-school-headscarf-ban-un-says/)?