Vermont high school banned from tournaments after refusing to play team with transgender player

Authored by cbssports.com and submitted by raider1v11
image for Vermont high school banned from tournaments after refusing to play team with transgender player

The Vermont girls high school basketball team that forfeited out of a tournament in February after refusing to play against a team with a transgender player has been declared ineligible to participate in future tournaments, the Vermont Principals' Association announced this week. The ban will apply to all sports.

"With feedback from membership at large, our Diversity Equity and Inclusion in Activities Committee, and our Activity Standards Committee, The VPA's Executive Council met today, March 13th, 2023 to discuss the relevant forfeiture," reads a statement from the VPA. "The result was a determination that policies have been violated at the school level, thus there is an immediate determination of ineligibility for Mid-Vermont Christian in VPA sanctioned activities and tournaments going forward."

Mid Vermont Christian School forfeited out of the Vermont Division IV girls basketball state tournament after refusing to play against Long Trail School on Feb. 21 in the first round. Long Trail has a transgender player on its roster, but according to Valley News, MVCS was the only opponent to have an issue with that all season.

In a statement, MVCS head of school Vicky Fogg explained that the reason for the forfeit was her school did not think it was fair to have the girls team play against an opponent with a biological male because it "jeopardizes the fairness of the game and the safety of our players."

After the meeting on March 13, the VPA sent the school a letter to the school saying that forfeit and the rationality behind it "violates VPA Policies which are aligned with Vermont state law."

"Specifically, the school's actions do not meet the expectations of the VPA's 1st and 2nd policy, Commitment to Racial, Gender-Fair, and Disability Awareness and Policy of Gender Identity, respectively" reads the letter. "Thus, Mid-Vermont Christian school is ineligible to participate in VPA activities going forward. The prorated dues will be returned to you via check."

As of 2022, Vermont private schools are expected to follow the state's anti-discrimination rules if they want state funding. Earlier this year, MVCS and another religiously affiliated school told the Vermont Board of Education that they wanted to reserve the right not to follow all of the anti-discrimination laws due to their religious beliefs.

VolcanoCatch on March 15th, 2023 at 06:26 UTC »

Sometimes medical conditions can exclude a person from sports. It doesn't mean they are invalid as a person or should avoid treatment, but just like cis people who have conditions that require steroid or other treatment, it means they are often disqualified from competitive sports. For MTF trans athletes, that may mean they don't qualify for the womens league, but can still join the mens (open) league.

For everyone saying its just a small amount of MTF athletes, that argument can be reflected back as well. Why challenge the entire concept of womens sports for a small amount of athletes? Respectfully the sporting thing to do is acknowledge the physical advantage (particularly for high schools minors not undergoing hormone treatment yet) and not interrupt half of the population's only competitive option. Women's sports only became protected in the 70s and it's already challanged by removing the entire point of separated levels.

reenactment on March 15th, 2023 at 05:52 UTC »

I don’t know why sports is the battleground for this. It’s simple. Men’s sports are the OPEN division. Any man, trans, female can compete in the men’s division on men’s teams. Women’s division is protected for a reason. No one is telling trans females they can’t play sports, go do it in the open division. If you have a desire to play it with biological females then you have a problem. This isn’t some exclusionary tactic. It’s protecting opportunities for female athletes.

TwoFrontHitters on March 15th, 2023 at 02:35 UTC »

Is this a diversion created by the news while some wealthy people bankrupt some poor people? Very sus.