Video shows Florida deputy fatally shoot armed man whose brother lay dying after hotel altercation

Authored by nbcnews.com and submitted by notoleranceforjerks
image for Video shows Florida deputy fatally shoot armed man whose brother lay dying after hotel altercation

Video released last week shows the moment this month when a Florida deputy fatally shot an armed man, whose brother was nearby and bleeding to death after an altercation at an Orlando hotel.

Brothers Dylan Michael Jimenez, 21, and Bryan Matthew Richardson, 28, died after the incident, the Orange County Sheriff’s Office said.

The sheriff’s office on Friday released body camera video of deputies responding to a shooting at 12:30 p.m. Aug. 6 outside the Orlando hotel, where they found Jimenez wounded from having been shot.

The Orange County, Fla., Sheriff's Office released body camera video of an alleged gunman being fatally shot on Aug. 6. Orange County Sheriff's Office

The video begins when a deputy is speaking to a man who says he is a paramedic and is treating a wounded man on the ground who is shot on the right side of his chest.

The deputy can be heard in the video telling the paramedic that they’re going to treat the wounded man by putting a chest seal on him. The deputy then instructs the paramedic to put the injured man on his back and to open his airway.

Shouts of “he has a gun, he has a gun” are then heard on the video. Also heard is someone shouting that the person with the gun is pointing it at people.

The deputy then moves toward a man and orders him to “drop the gun,” while a second deputy appears to struggle with the man’s left hand. The video then shows the unidentified deputy firing several rounds at the nearby man. The wounded man is then seen collapsing by a pickup truck.

Richardson and Jimenez were pronounced dead at a hospital, police have said.

Before deputies arrived outside the hotel, officials said, Jimenez and Richardson had an altercation with a third man outside the hotel. Jimenez and the third man, who wasn't identified, shot each other, and the brothers then ran to the north side of the hotel, where Richardson fell to the ground, officials said. The man who is alleged to have shot Richardson survived, authorities said.

Orange County Sheriff John Mina, in an introduction to the video, said his office is “committed to transparency and believes it is critical to maintaining accountability and enhancing trust between this agency and the public.”

The Florida Department of Law Enforcement will conduct an independent investigation, Mina said. The deputy who fired his weapon was placed on paid administrative leave, Mina said. He has been with the sheriff’s office since 2018, agency officials said.

No one with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement could be reached for comment Monday.

Mark NeJame, the lawyer for the family of the deceased brothers, credited Mina for releasing the video "on his own volition."

He said, however, that it appears the deputy who fatally shot Richardson "clearly used excessive force and overreacted."

NeJame said that, according to witnesses, Richardson was protecting his wounded brother and the crowd near Jimenez because a gunman was at large.

NeJame said Richardson had just witnessed his brother getting shot and was most likely in shock. He added that it's unknown whether the deputy in the video knew Richardson was armed before his fatal shooting.

The shooting was an "unnecessary use of violence against someone who had already been victimized — Bryan," NeJame said.

Institutional-GUH on August 31st, 2022 at 13:06 UTC »

Holy fuck. I haven’t seen any news coverage on this yet, but the video is chilling and the cop needs to be held accountable for straight up murder.

Adorable-Ganache6561 on August 31st, 2022 at 12:05 UTC »

How terrible for their family. Both brothers dying in such a violent way within minutes of each other. RIP

notoleranceforjerks on August 31st, 2022 at 11:37 UTC »

Since I'm afraid to change the headline, FYI it leaves out that he had already surrendered his weapon and was not resisting. The video shows this very clearly. https://youtu.be/IR8KliyFlNY

Witnesses report he had been asked to assist by the officer who calmly took his weapon just before he was shot to death. I don't have a good source for that, but will include it when I do.

Edit:

This article goes into more detail, explicitly points out that he was disarmed without resistance prior to being shot, and includes the claim from the family's lawyer that he had been requested to provide cover by the same deputy who calmly disarmed him just before he was shot to death.

NeJame claimed that the third man involved in the shooting was a "known menace and danger" to the residents of Heritage Hotel. He said Richardson was only holding his gun to provide protection to the first deputy on scene, as well as to the former EMT who was helping his brother, as the third man was still present in the area. He also claimed that the first deputy on the scene, the deputy's female partner, knew Richardson was armed and gave him permission for the same.