Opinion : Israel’s semi-neutrality on Ukraine can’t last

Authored by washingtonpost.com and submitted by Boronickel

We know this because he flew on Saturday. Bennett is an Orthodox Jew, for whom the one justification for traveling on the Sabbath is possibly saving human life. With him as his interpreter was Kharkhiv-born Housing Minister Zeev Elkin, also Orthodox. I have many doubts about both men, but I’m certain they wouldn’t have flown on Shabbat without that hope.

Thus far, nothing has happened to realize that hope. Leaks about what led to it should be treated with extreme skepticism. Whatever is reported now will be disproved by documents that will be declassified in three decades. The trip was so secret that, reportedly , Bennett only notified the Israeli military at the last moment and Elkin drove himself to the airport himself to avoid involving a ministerial driver.

So Bennett believed he might somehow stop the killing, but human actions usually have multiple motives. Altruism can also be instrumental. By inserting himself as mediator, Bennett was serving two kinds of self-interest.

One was personal, in the realm of domestic politics. Bennett is an almost accidental leader of a governing coalition held together only by rejection of ex-prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Inevitably, Bennett seeks to show that the country can do without his predecessor. Netanyahu campaigned on the claim that he was in a “different league” from all other Israeli politicians, and that his diplomatic skills gave him unique access to world leaders — including Russian dictator Vladimir Putin. For Bennett, presenting himself as the first Western leader able to sit down with Putin since the invasion was an irresistible opportunity.

The second interest was national. The peacekeeping bid provided an explanation — or an excuse — for the Israeli government’s all-too-noticeable standoffishness toward the Western coalition against Russia. Israel hasn’t joined European and U.S. sanctions against Russia. As of this writing, one can still book a direct flight from Moscow to Tel Aviv. Israel is sending humanitarian aid to Ukraine — but not military supplies. It took public and legal pressure for hard-line Interior Minister Ayelet Shaked to loosen the entry criteria for Ukrainian refugees.

Putin’s willingness to receive Bennett as a go-between is a payoff for half-neutrality. For that matter, so is Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s proposal over the weekend that negotiations with Russia take place in Jerusalem.

But those responses, in themselves, don’t explain Israel’s policy. One reason for Israel’s fence-sitting is its strange arrangement with Russia in Syria — where Russia controls the skies but allows Israel to continue its air campaign against Hezbollah and the group’s Iranian sponsor.

That’s only an example of a larger pattern. “Israel looks at the [Ukraine] crisis through an entirely different lens than Western countries, and more and more like most Middle Eastern countries, even though it’s a democracy,” ex-Knesset member Ksenia Svetlova, now a research fellow at the Institute for Policy and Strategy at Reichman University and Mitvim, the Israeli Institute for Regional Foreign Policies, told me.

That lens is regional. On one hand, Russia “is much closer ... than the United States is,” and “it’s increasing its presence in the Mediterranean basin,” she says. On the other, America has “left without leaving,” drawing down forces and lowering the Middle East in its priorities. Russia has stepped into the vacuum.

Svetlova also says she is concerned Israel looks at the war in Ukraine “as something … not next to [Israel’s] borders.” This view ignores the moral dimension of Russia’s unprovoked and brutal attempt to overrun its neighbor. And that’s not the only reason it’s a misguided perspective.

“I suspect that the government hasn’t absorbed that the world has changed ... that Russia is now a pariah state, like North Korea,” Svetlova says. In such a global event, maneuvering between superpowers is no longer an option. Whatever regional alliances Israel has formed are far less substantial than being part of the West. Fence-sitting, Svetlova explains, “distances us from our natural camp ... the United States and Europe.”

Israel’s hesitations also carry a message for Washington: Russia’s role in the Middle East is a result of American retreat, and Russia’s cruelty in Syria now looks like an ignored warning of its crimes today in Ukraine. In the return to stark confrontation reminiscent of the Cold War, the United States cannot afford to treat the Middle East as a minor priority.

Aniket2297 on March 23rd, 2022 at 12:23 UTC »

I am really unaware of Israeli domestic politics and would love if anyone knowledgeable on the topic can provide me with some more information, but as far as I understand the current stance of the Israeli government, is somehow based on the domestic Soviet Jewish population. As they feel some sort of connection to the current Russian government.

Also as to the issue of the Middle East, with the grain shortage which is expected to come about due to the war, they are also trying to ensure somewhat links with Russia to ensure grain import to ensure stability in the region (or even as a bargaining chip).

Lastly, would the issue of weakening of Russian position in the middle east supposedly being "taken over" by Turkey be a factor in their action?

Boronickel on March 23rd, 2022 at 11:46 UTC »

Submission Statement:

An opinion piece on how Israel is maintaining an increasingly uncomfortable neutral stance on Ukraine. While it joined in the UN vote to condemn Russia and supplied humanitarian aid to Ukraine, the reluctance to join in Western sanctions and cut ties make it a conspicuous outlier, especially when compared to others traditionally neutral states like Singapore and Switzerland.

Some reasons:

As the author mentioned, Bennett is hoping to play peacemaker, and therefore cannot show partisanship.

While willing to take in Ukrainian Jewish refugees, Israel also has to deal with Russian Jewish oligarchs looking to seek safe haven.

Some have drawn parallels between Ukraine and Palestine.

As stated in the piece, Russia is kingmaker in the Middle East with the winding down of US operations in the region and Israel cannot afford to jeopardise relations with its neighbours, which only normalised recently.

This discomfort was in full display in Zelensky's speech to the Knesset. His attempt to appeal to lawmakers by invoking the Holocaust caused huge controversy, in contrast to the unanimous approval he received from other parliamentary bodies.

AutoModerator on March 23rd, 2022 at 11:45 UTC »

Post a submission statement in one hour or your post will be removed. Rules / Wiki Resources

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.