When Religion Hurts: Structural Sexism and Health in Religious Congregations

An emerging line of research has begun to document the relationship between structural sexism and health. This work shows that structural sexism—defined as systematic gender inequality in power and resources—within U.S. state-level institutions and within marriages can shape individuals’ physical health. In the present study, we use a novel dataset created by linking two nationally representative surveys (the General Social Survey and the National Congregations Study) to explore the health consequences of structural sexism within another setting: religious institutions. Although religious participation is generally associated with positive health outcomes, many religious institutions create and reinforce a high degree of structural sexism, which is harmful for health. Prior research has not reconciled these seemingly conflicting patterns. We find that among religious participants, women who attend sexist religious institutions report significantly worse self-rated health than do those who attend more inclusive congregations. Furthermore, only women who attend inclusive religious institutions exhibit a health advantage relative to non-participants. We observe marginal to no statistically significant effects among men. Our results suggest the health benefits of religious participation do not extend to groups that are systematically excluded from power and status within their religious institutions.

adams, jimi . 2007 . “ Stained Glass Makes the Ceiling Visible: Organizational Opposition to Women in Congregational Leadership .” Gender and Society 21(1): 80 – 105 .

Adler, Nancy E. 2009 . “ Health Disparities through a Psychological Lens .” American Psychologist 64(8):663–73.

Aizer, Anna . 2010 . “ The Gender Wage Gap and Domestic Violence .” The American Economic Review 100(4): 1847 –59.

Avishai, Orit . 2016 . “ Theorizing Gender from Religion Cases: Agency, Feminist Activism, and Masculinity .” Sociology of Religion 77(3):261–79.

Avishai, Orit, Gerber, Lynne, Randles, Jennifer. 2013 . “ The Feminist Ethnographer’s Dilemma: Reconciling Progressive Research Agendas with Fieldwork Realities .” Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 42(4): 394 –426.

Baker, Joseph O., Whitehead, Andrew L. 2016 . “ Gendering (Non)Religion: Politics, Education, and Gender Gaps in Secularity in the United States .” Social Forces 94(4): 1623 –45.

Bartkowski, John P. 2001 . Remaking the Godly Marriage: Gender Negotiation in Evangelical Families. New Brunswick, NJ : Rutgers University Press .

Bartkowski, John P. 2007 . “ Connections and Contradictions: Exploring the Complex Linkages between Faith and Family .” Pp. 153–66 in Everyday Religion: Observing Modern Religious Lives, edited by Ammerman, N. T. Oxford, UK : Oxford University Press

Bartkowski, John P., Shah, Sarah. 2014 . “ Religion and Gender Inequality .” In Religion and Inequality in America: Research and Theory on Religion’s Role in Stratification, edited by Keister, L., Sherkat, D. E. New York : Cambridge University Press .

Beard, Lucas, Dunn, Jonathan, Huang, Jess, Krivkovich, Alexis. 2020 . “ Shattering the Glass Screen .” Gender Equity in Media and Entertainment, McKinsey (https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/technology-media-and-telecommunications/our-insights/shattering-the-glass-screen).

Bonilla-Silva, Eduardo . 1997 . “ Rethinking Racism: Toward a Structural Interpretation .” American Sociological Review 62(3):465–80.

Braveman, Paula, Gottlieb, Laura. 2014 . “ The Social Determinants of Health: It’s Time to Consider the Causes of the Causes .” Public Health Reports 129( Suppl 2 ): 19 –31.

Brusco, Elizabeth E. 1995 . The Reformation of Machismo: Evangelical Conversion and Gender in Colombia. Austin : University of Texas Press .

Burke, Kelsy . 2012 . “ Women’s Agency in Gender-Traditional Religions: A Review of Four Approaches .” Sociology Compass 6(2):122–33.

Cadge, Wendy . 2004 . “ Gendered Religious Organizations: The Case of Theravada Buddhism in America .” Gender and Society 18(6):777–93.

Catalyst . 2019 . “ Women CEOs of the S&P 500 .” American Women in Politics (https://www.catalyst.org/research/women-ceos-of-the-sp-500/).

CAWP . 2019 . “ Women in State Legislatures 2019 .” Center for American Women in Politics (https://www.cawp.rutgers.edu/women-state-legislature-2019).

Chaves, Mark . 1997 . Ordaining Women: Culture and Conflict in Religious Organizations. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .

Chaves, Mark . 2017 . American Religion: Contemporary Trends. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .

Chaves, Mark, Anderson, Shawna L. 2008 . “ Continuity and Change in American Congregations: Introducing the Second Wave of the National Congregations Study .” Sociology of Religion 69(4):415–40.

Chaves, Mark, Anderson, Shawna, Eagle, Alison. 2014 . “ National Congregations Study, Cumulative Data File and Codebook .” Durham, NC : Duke University, Department of Sociology .

Cobb, Ryon J., Üsküp, Dilara K., Jefferson, Steven T. 2017 . “ Congregational Composition and Explanations for Racial Inequality among Black Religious Affiliates .” Race and Social Problems 9(2):163–69.

Cotter, David, Hermsen, Joan M., Vanneman, Reeve. 2011 . “ The End of the Gender Revolution? Gender Role Attitudes from 1977 to 2008 .” American Journal of Sociology 117(1):259–89.

Collins, Caitlyn, Landivar, Liana Christin, Ruppanner, Leah, Scarborough, William J. 2020 . “ COVID-19 and the Gender Gap in Work Hours .” Gender Work & Organization (https://doi.org/10.1111/gwao.12506).

Connell, R. W. 2012 . “ Gender, Health and Theory: Conceptualizing the Issue, in Local and World Perspective .” Social Science & Medicine 74(11): 1675 –83.

Courtenay, Will H . 2000 . “ Constructions of Masculinity and Their Influence on Men’s Well-Being: A Theory of Gender and Health .” Social Science & Medicine 50(10): 1385 –401.

Denton, Margaret, Prus, Steven, Walters, Vivienne. 2004 . “ Gender Differences in Health: A Canadian Study of the Psychosocial, Structural and Behavioural Determinants of Health .” Social Science & Medicine 58(12): 2585 –2600 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2003.09.008).

DeRogatis, Amy . 2015 . Saving Sex. New York : Oxford University Press .

Diefendorf, Sarah . 2019 . “ Contemporary Evangelical Responses to Feminism and the Imagined Secular .” Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 44(4): 1003 –26.

Edgell, Penny . 2012 . “ A Cultural Sociology of Religion: New Directions .” Annual Review of Sociology 38:247–65.

Edgell, Penny . 2013 . Religion and Family in a Changing Society. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .

Ellison, Christopher G., Bartkowski, John P. 2002 . “ Conservative Protestantism and the Division of Household Labor among Married Couples .” Journal of Family Issues 23(8):950–85.

Ellison, Christopher G., Bartkowski, John P., Anderson, Kristin L. 1999 . “ Are There Religious Variations in Domestic Violence?” Journal of Family Issues 20(1): 87 –113.

Ellison, Christopher G., Krause, Neal M., Shepherd, Bryan C., Chaves, Mark A. 2009 . “ Size, Conflict, and Opportunities for Interaction: Congregational Effects on Members’ Anticipated Support and Negative Interaction .” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 48(1): 1 –15 (https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-5906.2009.01426.x).

Ellison, Christopher G., Lee, Jinwoo. 2010 . “ Spiritual Struggles and Psychological Distress: Is There a Dark Side of Religion?” Social Indicators Research 98(3):501–17.

Ellison, Christopher G., Levin, Jeffrey S. 1998 . “ The Religion-Health Connection: Evidence, Theory, and Future Directions .” Health Education & Behavior 25(6): 700 –720.

England, Paula . 2010 . “ The Gender Revolution: Uneven and Stalled .” Gender & Society 24(2):149–66.

Exline, Julie Juola, Rose, Eric. 2013 . “ Religious and Spiritual Struggles .” Pp. 380–98 in Handbook of the Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, edited by Paloutzian, R. F., Park, C. L. New York : Guilford Press .

Fenstermaker, Berk, Sarah . 1985 . The Gender Factory: The Apportionment of Work in American Households. New York : Plenum .

Ferguson, Todd W. 2018 . “ Female Leadership and Role Congruity within the Clergy: Communal Leaders Experience No Gender Differences Yet Agentic Women Continue to Suffer Backlash .” Sex Roles 78(5–6):409–22.

Gallagher, Sally . 2004 a. “ The Marginalization of Evangelical Feminism .” Sociology of Religion 65(3):215–37.

Gallagher, Sally . 2004 b. “ Where Are the Antifeminist Evangelicals? Evangelical Identity, Subcultural Location, and Attitudes toward Feminism .” Gender and Society 18(4):451–72

Garcia, Ginny, Ellison, Christopher G., Sunil, Thankam S., Hill, Terrence D. 2013 . “ Religion and Selected Health Behaviors among Latinos in Texas .” Journal of Religion and Health 52(1): 18 –31.

George, Linda K., Ellison, Christopher G., Larson, David B. 2002 . “ Explaining the Relationships between Religious Involvement and Health .” Psychological Inquiry 13(3): 190 –200.

Geronimus, Arline T., Bound, John, Keene, Danya, Hicken, Margaret. 2007 . “ Black–White Differences in Age Trajectories of Hypertension Prevalence among Adult Women and Men, 1999–2002 .” Ethnicity & Disease 17(1): 40 –49.

Ghazal Read, Jen’nan . 2004 . “ Family, Religion, and Work among Arab American Women .” Journal of Marriage and Family 66(4): 1042 –50.

Goldin, Claudia, Katz, Lawrence F., Kuziemko, Ilyana. 2006 . “ The Homecoming of American College Women: The Reversal of the College Gender Gap .” Journal of Economic Perspectives 20(4):133–56.

Griffith, R. Marie . 1997 . God’s Daughters: Evangelical Women and the Power of Submission. Berkeley : University of California Press .

Hamel, Liz, Salganicoff, Alina. 2020 . “ Is There a Widening Gender Gap in Coronavirus Stress? ” KFF (https://www.kff.org/policy-watch/is-there-widening-gender-gap-in-coronavirus-stress/).

Hill, Terrence D., Bradshaw, Matt, Burdette, Amy M. 2016 . “ Health and Biological Functioning .” Pp. 11 –28 in Handbook of Religion and Society, edited by Yamane, D. Cham , Switzerland : Springer .

Hill, Terrence D., Burdette, Amy M., Idler, Ellen L. 2011 . “ Religious Involvement, Health Status, and Mortality Risk .” Pp. 533–46 in Handbook of Sociology of Aging, edited by Settersten, R. A, Angel, J. L. New York : Springer .

Hill, Terrence, André Christie-Mizell, C., Vaghela, Preeti, Mossakowski, Krysia, Johnson, Robert J. 2017 . “ Do Religious Struggles Mediate the Association between Day-to-Day Discrimination and Depressive Symptoms?” Religions 8(8): 134 (https://doi.org/10.3390/rel8080134).

Hill, Terrence D., Cobb, Ryon J. 2011 . “ Religious Involvement and Religious Struggles .” Pp. 239 –60 in Toward a Sociological Theory of Religion and Health, edited by Blasi, A. Leiden, Netherlands : Brill .

Homan, Patricia . 2017 . “ Political Gender Inequality and Infant Mortality in the United States, 1990–2012 .” Social Science & Medicine 182:127–35 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2017.04.024).

Homan, Patricia . 2019 . “ Structural Sexism and Health in the United States: A New Perspective on Health Inequality and the Gender System .” American Sociological Review 84(3): 486 –516 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0003122419848723).

Idler, Ellen L. 2004 . “ Religious Observance and Health: Theory and Research .” Pp. 20 –43 in Religious Influences on Health and Well-Being in the Elderly, edited by Warner Schaie, K., Krause, N., Booth, A. New York : Springer .

Idler, Ellen L., Benyamini, Yael. 1997 . “ Self-Rated Health and Mortality: A Review of Twenty-Seven Community Studies .” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 38(1): 21 –37.

Jylhä, Marja . 2009 . “ What Is Self-Rated Health and Why Does It Predict Mortality? Towards a Unified Conceptual Model .” Social Science & Medicine 69(3):307–16.

Koenig, Harold George. 1999 . “ Religion and Medicine .” Lancet 353(9166): 1804 .

Koenig, Harold George, King, Dana, Carson, Verna B. 2012 . Handbook of Religion and Health. New York : Oxford University Press .

Krause, Neal, Hayward, R. D. 2016 . “ Religion, Health, and Aging .” Pp. 251–70 in Handbook of Aging and the Social Sciences, edited by George, L., Ferraro, K. Waltham, MA : Academic Press .

Krause, Neal, Wulff, Keith M. 2004 . “ Religious Doubt and Health: Exploring the Potential Dark Side of Religion .” Sociology of Religion 65(1): 35 –56.

Krieger, Nancy . 2014 . “ Discrimination and Health Inequities .” In Social Epidemiology, edited by Berkman, L. F., Kawachi, I., Maria Glymour, M. New York : Oxford University Press .

Link, Bruce G., Phelan, Jo. 1995 . “ Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Disease .” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 35: 80 –94.

Marmot, Michael G. 2005 . “ Social Determinants of Health Inequalities .” The Lancet 365(9464): 1099 –1104.

Marmot, Michael G. 2006 . “ Status Syndrome: A Challenge to Medicine .” JAMA 295(11): 1304 –7.

Maselko, Joanna, Kubzansky, Laura D. 2006 . “ Gender Differences in Religious Practices, Spiritual Experiences and Health: Results from the US General Social Survey .” Social Science & Medicine 62(11): 2848 –60.

McCullough, Michael E., Hoyt, William T., Larson, David B., Koenig, Harold G., Thoresen, Carl. 2000 . “ Religious Involvement and Mortality: A Meta-analytic Review .” Health Psychology 19(3):211–22.

McCullough, Michael E., Laurenceau, Jean-Philippe. 2005 . “ Religiousness and the Trajectory of Self-Rated Health across Adulthood .” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 31(4):560–73 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167204271657).

McFarland, Michael J. 2010 . “ Religion and Mental Health among Older Adults: Do the Effects of Religious Involvement Vary by Gender?” Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences 65(5):621–30.

McPherson, J. Miller . 1982 . “ Hypernetwork Sampling: Duality and Differentiation among Voluntary Organizations .” Social Networks 3(4):225–49 (https://doi.org/10.1016/0378-8733(82)90001-6).

McPherson, Miller . 2001 . “ Sampling Strategies for the Arts: A Hypernetwork Approach .” Poetics 28(4): 291 –306 (https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-422X(01)80005-X).

Mirola, William A. 1999 . “ A Refuge for Some: Gender Differences in the Relationship between Religious Involvement and Depression .” Sociology of Religion 60(4):419–37.

Nason-Clark, Nancy . 2000 . “ Making the Sacred Safe: Woman Abuse and Communities of Faith .” Sociology of Religion 61(4):349–68.

National Congregations Study (NCS) . 2019 . “ Methodology – National Congregations Study .” Retrieved September 23 , 2020 (https://sites.duke.edu/ncsweb/methodology/).

Norton, Maria C., Skoog, Ingmar, Franklin, Lynn M., Corcoran, Christopher, Tschanz, JoAnn T., Zandi, Peter P., Breitner, John C. S., Welsh-Bohmer, Kathleen A., Steffens, David C. for the Cache County Investigators . 2006 . “ Gender Differences in the Association between Religious Involvement and Depression: The Cache County (Utah) Study .” The Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences 61(3):129–36.

Pargament, Kenneth I., Koenig, Harold G., Tarakeshwar, Nalini, Hahn, June. 2001 . “ Religious Struggle as a Predictor of Mortality among Medically Ill Elderly Patients: A 2-Year Longitudinal Study .” Archives of Internal Medicine 161(15): 1881 –5.

Pascoe, Elizabeth A., Richman, Laura Smart. 2009 . “ Perceived Discrimination and Health: A Meta-Analytic Review .” Psychological Bulletin 135(4):531–54.

Pearlin, Leonard I., Menaghan, Elizabeth G., Lieberman, Morton A., Mullan, Joseph T. 1981 . “ The Stress Process .” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 22(4):337–56.

Pepin, Joanna R., Cotter, David A. 2018 . “ Separating Spheres? Diverging Trends in Youth’s Gender Attitudes about Work and Family .” Journal of Marriage and Family 80(1): 7 –24.

Perry, Samuel L. 2019 . Addicted to Lust: Pornography in the Lives of Conservative Protestants. New York : Oxford University Press .

Perry, Samuel L. 2020 . “ The Bible as a Product of Cultural Power: The Case of Gender Ideology in the English Standard Version .” Sociology of Religion 81(1): 68 –92.

Quamruzzaman, Amm, Lange, Matthew. 2016 . “ Female Political Representation and Child Health: Evidence from a Multilevel Analysis .” Social Science & Medicine 171: 48 –57.

Ridgeway, Cecilia L., Correll, Shelley J. 2004 . “ Unpacking the Gender System: A Theoretical Perspective on Gender Beliefs and Social Relations .” Gender and Society 18(4):501–31 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243204265269).

Risman, Barbara J. 2004 . “ Gender as a Social Structure: Theory Wrestling with Activism .” Gender and Society 18(4):429–50.

Ross, Catherine E., Masters, Ryan K., Hummer, Robert A. 2012 . “ Education and the Gender Gaps in Health and Mortality .” Demography 49(4): 1157 –1183 (https://doi.org/10.1007/s13524-012-0130-z).

Scarborough, William J., Risman, Barbara J. 2018 . “ Gender Inequality .” Pp. 339–62 in The Cambridge Handbook of Social Problems, edited by Trevino, A. J. New York : Cambridge University Press (https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108656184.020).

Schieman, Scott, Bierman, Alex, Ellison, Christopher G. 2010 . “ Religious Involvement, Beliefs about God, and the Sense of Mattering among Older Adults .” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 49(3):517–35.

Smith, Tom W., Davern, Michael, Freese, Jeremy, Morgan, Stephen. 2018 . “ General Social Surveys, 1972–2018 [machine-readable data file] .” Principal Investigator, Tom W. Smith; Co-Principal Investigators, Michael Davern, Jeremy Freese, and Stephen Morgan; sponsored by National Science Foundation, NORC at the University of Chicago [producer and distributor]. Data accessed from the GSS Data Explorer website (http://gssdataexplorer.norc.org).

Strawbridge, William J., Shema, Sarah J., Cohen, Richard D., Kaplan, George A. 2001 . “ Religious Attendance Increases Survival by Improving and Maintaining Good Health Behaviors, Mental Health, and Social Relationships .” Annals of Behavioral Medicine 23(1): 68 –74 (https://doi.org/10.1207/S15324796ABM2301_10).

Strawbridge, William J., Shema, Sarah J., Cohen, Richard D., Roberts, Robert E., Kaplan, George A. 1998 . “ Religiosity Buffers Effects of Some Stressors on Depression but Exacerbates Others .” Journals of Gerontology: Social Sciences 53B: S118 –26.

Umberson, Debra, Kroeger, Rhiannon A. 2016 . “ Gender, Marriage, and Health for Same-Sex and Different-Sex Couples: The Future Keeps Arriving .” Pp. 189 –213 in Gender and Couple Relationships, National Symposium on Family Issues , edited by McHale, S. M., King, V., Van Hook, J., Booth, A. New York : Springer .

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics . 2019 . “ Highlights of Women’s Earnings in 2018 .” BLS Report 1083 (https://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/womens-earnings/2018/home.htm).

West, Candace, Zimmerman, Don H. 1987 . “ Doing Gender .” Gender & Society 1(2):125–51.

Whitehead, Andrew L. 2013 . “ Gendered Organizations and Inequality Regimes: Gender, Homosexuality, and Inequality within Religious Congregations .” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 52(3):476–93.

World Economic Forum . 2017 . “ Global Gender Gap Report ” (https://www.weforum.org/reports/the-global-gender-gap-report-2017).

Yang, Yang Claire, Schorpp, Kristen, Harris, Kathleen Mullan. 2014 . “ Social Support, Social Strain and Inflammation: Evidence from a National Longitudinal Study of U.S. Adults .” Social Science & Medicine 107:124–35.

Yukich, Grace, Braunstein, Ruth. 2014 . “ Encounters at the Religious Edge: Variation in Religious Expression across Interfaith Advocacy and Social Movement Settings .” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 53(4): 791 –807.

Yukich, Grace, Edgell, Penny, eds. 2020 . Religion Is Raced: Understanding American Religion in the Twenty-First Century. New York : NYU Press .