‘The Heat Is On’: Legal Experts Say Postmaster General Committed ‘Stunning’ Array of Crimes, Including ‘Wire Fraud’

Authored by lawandcrime.com and submitted by Twoweekswithpay
image for ‘The Heat Is On’: Legal Experts Say Postmaster General Committed ‘Stunning’ Array of Crimes, Including ‘Wire Fraud’

U.S. Postmaster General Louis DeJoy allegedly ascended to the heights of federal government employment by way of what is known as a straw donor scheme. Legal experts say the alleged facts are evidence of a crime that should be easy to prosecute.

The allegations are tidily summed up in the headline of a Sunday afternoon story by the Washington Post: “Louis DeJoy’s rise as GOP fundraiser was powered by contributions from coworkers who were later reimbursed, former employees say.”

Pressed to account for the behavior at issue, a close parsing of DeJoy’s response through a spokeswoman shows he didn’t exactly deny the story:

Here is DeJoy’s response to WAPO article. I couldn’t find the denial pic.twitter.com/zsQpvCpFYu — Daniel Uhlfelder (@DWUhlfelderLaw) September 6, 2020

The statement did say, however, that DeJoy “sought and received” legal advice to make sure he had “complied with any and all laws.”

Under federal law, having someone else make a campaign finance contribution on your behalf is expressly illegal.

Per a Federal Election Commission (FEC) explainer:

Contributions in the Name of Another are Strictly Prohibited Reimbursing someone for a contribution or otherwise contributing in the name of another person can result in substantial civil penalties and jail time. The FEC and the Department of Justice have prosecuted several such cases over the last few years. These violations sometimes occur when an individual who has already contributed up to the limit to a campaign gives money to another person to make a contribution to the same candidate.

DeJoy, a resident of North Carolina, caught the attention of the Tarheel State’s attorney general over the weekend.

“It is against the law to directly or indirectly reimburse someone for a political contribution,” North Carolina Attorney General Josh Stein (D) tweeted. State law also prohibits the practice and there is no statute of limitations for violations of the state statute–which are felonies.

Stein declined to comment further aside from saying that the “appropriate” authorities should investigate the claims.

And while any such potential investigation is unlikely to be timely viz. the upcoming general election, several legal experts believe that DeJoy could be in legal jeopardy—or, rather, that he should be.

“Using straw donors is a crime because it allows fundraisers to cheat campaign contribution limits,” said University of Michigan Law Professor Barbara McQuade. “If report is true that DeJoy committed this conduct in 2016, then the heat is on. Five-year statute of limitations won’t run until 2021.”

“Not to mention layup of a wire fraud case,” added California-based law professor and legal columnist Harry Litman, referencing the pliable federal statute that allows prosecutors to bring charges for almost any sort of fraud imaginable.

Attorney George Conway, fresh off of a self-imposed temporary Twitter exile, chimed in with a much further afield suggestion:

also possibly tax fraud to the extent straw-donor reimbursement came in the form of tax-deductible employee wages — George Conway (@gtconway3d) September 7, 2020

But, to others, such rapid analyses leave several questions open:

If Postmaster DeJoy committed campaign finance & other crimes that are within the statute of limitations, the question is, will Barr’s DOJ bring a timely prosecution? Will they investigate at all? DOJ can only do its job when people have confidence in its integrity. — Joyce Alene (@JoyceWhiteVance) September 6, 2020

Former DOJ attorney and administrative law expert Sasha Samberg-Champion suggested that it isn’t just the “brazenness” of DeJoy’s “illegal conduct” that’s “stunning”:

It really is amazing that we now have fairly strong evidence that the Postmaster General secured his job on the back of systemic and intentional violations of campaign finance laws . . . and nothing happens. https://t.co/GWoP2hrarv — Sasha Samberg-Champion (@ssamcham) September 7, 2020

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

brunnock on September 7th, 2020 at 15:30 UTC »

Barr is too busy planning an October surprise.

jello3d on September 7th, 2020 at 15:24 UTC »

Mmmm... state felonies. Deliciously unpardonable.

Twoweekswithpay on September 7th, 2020 at 14:55 UTC »

And while any such potential investigation is unlikely to be timely viz. the upcoming general election, several legal experts believe that DeJoy could be in legal jeopardy—or, rather, that he should be.

“Using straw donors is a crime because it allows fundraisers to cheat campaign contribution limits,” said University of Michigan Law Professor Barbara McQuade. “If report is true that DeJoy committed this conduct in 2016, then the heat is on. Five-year statute of limitations won’t run until 2021.”

“Not to mention layup of a wire fraud case,” added California-based law professor and legal columnist Harry Litman, referencing the pliable federal statute that allows prosecutors to bring charges for almost any sort of fraud imaginable.

[George Conway] also possibly tax fraud to the extent straw-donor reimbursement came in the form of tax-deductible employee wages.

So, yeah, DuJoy is learning what happens when you go all-in for Trump and try to tear down one of the foundations of our country: the American people will not go down quietly! 😡

As the article mentions, Barr probably won’t investigate the matter at all. But, once Biden takes office, the DOJ has until 2021 to teach DuJoy and all republicans that “crime doesn’t pay!”