Web inventor Tim Berners-Lee unveils plan to save the internet

Authored by dw.com and submitted by Molire
image for Web inventor Tim Berners-Lee unveils plan to save the internet

Tim Berners-Lee, a British engineer credited with having invented the World Wide Web in 1989, has released an ambitious plan detailing steps for better online governance, addressing problems like misinformation, data surveillance and censorship.

The Contract for the Web was created by Berners-Lee's World Wide Web Foundation in cooperation with representatives from governments, companies and civil society to "keep knowledge freely available," while strengthening laws, regulations and companies "to ensure pursuit of profit is not at the expense of human rights and democracy."

"If we don't act now — and act together — to prevent the web being misused by those who want to exploit, divide and undermine, we are at risk of squandering" its potential for good, Berners-Lee said in a statement released by the WWW Foundation on Monday.

Read more: Who gets to participate in the online revolution?

The plan is backed by more than 150 organizations, including internet giants like Google, Microsoft and Facebook, along with interest groups like Reporters Without Borders. The governments of Germany and France have also indicated their support for the plan.

Read more: Germany announces plans to combat far-right extremism and online hate speech

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Free speech or illegal content? Whether hate speech, propaganda or activism, governments across the globe have upped efforts to curb content deemed illegal from circulating on social networks. From drawn-out court cases to blanket bans, DW examines how some countries try to stop the circulation of illicit content while others attempt to regulate social media.

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Social media law After a public debate in Germany, a new law on social media came into effect in October. The legislation imposes heavy fines on social media companies, such as Facebook, for failing to take down posts containing hate speech. Facebook and other social media companies have complained about the law, saying that harsh rules might lead to unnecessary censorship.

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Right to be forgotten In 2014, the European Court of Justice ruled that European citizens had the right to request search engines, such as Google and Bing, remove "inaccurate, inadequate, irrelevant or excessive" search results linked to their name. Although Google has complied with the ruling, it has done so reluctantly, warning that it could make the internet as "free as the world's least free place."

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Blanket ban In May 2017, Ukraine imposed sanctions on Russian social media platforms and web services. The blanket ban affected millions of Ukrainian citizens, many of whom were anxious about their data. The move prompted young Ukrainians to protest on the streets, calling for the government to reinstate access to platforms that included VKontakte (VK), Russia's largest social network.

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Safe Harbor In 2015, the European Court of Justice ruled that Safe Harbor, a 15-year-old pact between the US and EU that allowed the transfer of personal data without prior approval, was effectively invalid. Austrian law student Max Schrems launched the legal proceedings against Facebook in response to revelations made by former US National Security Agency (NSA) contractor, Edward Snowden.

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Regulation In China, the use of social media is highly regulated by the government. Beijing has effectively blocked access to thousands of websites and platforms, including Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Pinterest. Instead, China offers its citizens access to local social media platforms, such as Weibo and WeChat, which boast hundreds of millions of monthly users.

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Twitter bans Russia-linked accounts Many politicians and media outlets blame Russia's influence for Donald Trump's election victory in 2016. Moscow reportedly used Facebook, Twitter, Google, and Instagram to shape public opinion on key issues. In October 2017, Twitter suspended over 2,750 accounts due to alleged Russian propaganda. The platform also banned ads from RT (formerly Russia Today) and the Sputnik news agency.

Fighting for the internet: Social media, governments and tech companies Facebook announces propaganda-linked tool With social media under pressure for allowing alleged Russian meddling, Facebook announced a new project to combat such efforts in November 2017. The upcoming page will give users a chance to check if they "liked" or followed an alleged propaganda account on Facebook or Instagram. Meanwhile, Facebook has come under fire for not protecting user data in the wake of the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Author: Lewis Sanders IV (dj)

"I will stand up for the preservation of the free internet that we have grown to know and love in recent decades," German Economy Minister Peter Altmaier said in a statement released ahead of the UN Internet Governance Forum, being held this week in Berlin. Berners-Lee is due to speak at the forum on Monday.

Although the contract is not legally binding, it proposes frameworks for national laws that would protect online privacy and personal data.

The WWW Foundation criticizes current laws and institutions that it says fall short of protecting citizens and preventing the abuse of the technology in society, business and politics.

"The web needs radical intervention from all those who have power over its future," Berners-Lee wrote in a statement published Sunday night by the The New York Times.

"We're at a tipping point. How we respond to this abuse will determine whether the web lives up to its potential as a global force for good or leads us into a digital dystopia."

Berners-Lee also defended including Google and Facebook in composing the Contract for the Web. The companies have faced criticism from civil society for their data-collecting business models, and sensation-rewarding algorithms have been blamed for spreading misinformation and violating user data privacy.

Last week, Amnesty International said the companies' business models were a "threat to human rights."

"Having them in the room is really important," Berners-Lee said. "We feel that companies and governments deserve equal seats at the table.

"Citizens must hold those in power accountable, demand their digital rights be respected and help foster healthy conversation online."

Watch video 02:18 Share Google promises better data protection Send Facebook google+ Whatsapp Tumblr linkedin stumble Digg reddit Newsvine Permalink https://p.dw.com/p/3JaCS Google promises better data protection

Every day, DW's editors send out a selection of the day's hard news and quality feature journalism. You can sign up to receive it directly here.

4x4is16Legs on November 25th, 2019 at 09:00 UTC »

But when I click through to the “Contract for the Web” and see it’s endorsed by Facebook I get very confused...

kedde1x on November 25th, 2019 at 08:49 UTC »

Tim Berners-Lee is also heavily involved with the Solid project, which aims to make people in control over their own data. The idea is simple; each person can create one or more data pod with their own personal data in them, store the pod(s) wherever they want and perform access control on their own pods. They essentially are in full control over which application gets what data. It already works, we just need application developers to develop great apps for it.

Solid works on the cores of the Semantic Web, which Tim Berners-Lee was also one of the founders of. In my PhD I work with decentralization of the Semantic Web, which I think is key to achieve his plan of keeping knowledge freely available. Essentially, I try to make public knowledge graphs available at all times, to everyone.

There are a multitude of challenges ahead of us for all of this to be achieved: First, at some point we will have to take a stand against companies like Facebook. Second, we have to insist that public knowledge remain public, and third we have to overcome technical challenges such as in a heavily decentralized world, where data can be anywhere on the Web, how do we know where to look for specific data? This is exactly the sort of thing I am working on.

Edit: Since this is kinda blowing up I feel I need to clarify and disclaim a few things.

First, I am aware that Facebook, Google, etc. are free partly because you "pay them with your data" Noone is trying to completely remove this model either.

Solid focuses on giving you the choice. If you choose that you want a free option, that then can do what they want with your data, that is fine. Completely fine. But if you instead choose, you'd rather pay a monthly fee to avoid this, there should be options for that. The point is the choice, which there is none of today; if you want to participate, you have to use Facebook. With Solid, apps can request access to the same data. So you can use another app and still create events, posts, etc. with all your friends that instead uses another app (e.g. Facebook).

Of course, it is impossible to completely eliminate personal data misuse. But Solid can help make it a lot harder to pull off, which I am personally a fan of. I don't like the idea of giving in and accepting the way things are. So I'm trying to improve it.

I think this is a very important discussion to have, and I am glad we can have it in a civil manner ;)

Now a disclaimer: My research is not specifically aimed at Solid. It shares some technical challenges and my research could help Solid, but I am not directly involved with Solid. I just think, that it is possible and a good way forward.

Edit2: My first Gold and platinum, thanks! :)) I'm glad there are people who believe in the effort to improve a bad situation. Anyone can participate in the Semantic Web community as well, you are all very welcome!

Ariliescbk on November 25th, 2019 at 07:45 UTC »

"keep knowledge freely available"

Does that mean he'll address the issue of academic journals charging so much? /s