The Impact of Message Source on the Effectiveness of Communications About Climate Change

We conducted a survey experiment in which we presented 1,850 respondents with one of two versions of an appeal emphasizing either the threats to the environment or threats to national security of the United States as a result of climate change. The messages were attributed to one of four sources: Republican Party leaders, Democratic Party leaders, military officials, or climate scientists. The results reveal that messages attributed to military leaders, or to Republican Party leaders, can enhance the impact of the appeal. This finding underscores the importance that the source of any communication can have on its overall effectiveness.

Bartels, L. M. ( 2002 ). Beyond the running tally: Partisan bias in political perceptions . Political Behavior, 24, 117 - 150 .

Benegal, S. D., Scruggs, L. A. ( 2018 ). Correcting misinformation about climate change: The impact of partisanship in an experimental setting . Climatic Change, 148, 61 - 80 .

Berinsky, A. J., Huber, G. A., Lenz, G. S. ( 2012 ). Evaluating online labor markets for experimental research: Amazon.com’s Mechanical Turk . Political Analysis, 20, 351 - 368 .

Bickerstaff, K., Lorenzoni, I., Pidgeon, N. F., Poortinga, W., Simmons, P. ( 2008 ). Reframing nuclear power in the UK energy debate: Nuclear power, climate change mitigation and radioactive waste . Public Understanding of Science, 17, 145 - 169 .

Bolsen, T., Druckman, J. N. ( 2018 ). Do partisanship and politicization undermine the impact of a scientific consensus message about climate change? Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 21, 389 - 402 .

Bolsen, T., Druckman, J. N., Cook, F. L. ( 2014 ). The influence of partisan motivated reasoning on public opinion . Political Behavior, 36, 235 - 262 .

Bolsen, T., Kingsland, J., Palm, R. ( 2018 ). The impact of frames highlighting coastal flooding in the USA on climate change beliefs . Climatic Change, 147, 359 - 368 .

Bolsen, T., Shapiro, M. A. ( 2017 ). Strategic framing and persuasive messaging to influence climate change perceptions and decisions . In Oxford research encyclopedia of climate science. doi:10.1093/acrefore/9780190228620.013.435. Retrieved from http://understandgreen.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Strategic-framing-and-persuasive-messaging....pdf

Brewer, P. R., Ley, B. L. ( 2013 ). Whose science do you believe? Explaining trust in sources of scientific information about the environment . Science Communication, 35, 115 - 137 .

Campbell, T. H., Kay, A. C. ( 2014 ). Solution aversion: On the relation between ideology and motivated disbelief . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 107, 809 - 824 .

Chong, D., Druckman, J. N. ( 2007 ). Framing theory . Annual Review of Political Science, 10, 103 - 126 .

Cohen, G. L. ( 2003 ). Party over policy: The dominating impact of group influence on political beliefs . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85, 808 - 822 .

Cook, J., Lewandowsky, S. ( 2016 ). Rational irrationality: Modeling climate change belief polarization using Bayesian networks . Topics in Cognitive Science, 8, 160 - 179 .

Cook, J., Oreskes, N., Doran, P. T., Anderegg, W. R., Verheggen, B., Maibach, E. W., . . . Nuccitelli, D. ( 2016 ). Consensus on consensus: A synthesis of consensus estimates on human-caused global warming . Environmental Research Letters, 11, 048002 .

Dixon, G., Hmielowski, J., Ma, Y. ( 2017 ). Improving climate change acceptance among US conservatives through value-based message targeting . Science Communication, 39, 520 - 534 .

Dixon, G., Hubner, A. ( 2018 ). Neutralizing the effect of political worldviews by communicating scientific agreement: A thought-listing study . Science Communication, 40, 393 - 415 .

Druckman, J. N. ( 2001 a). On the limits of framing effects: Who can frame? Journal of Politics, 63, 1041 - 1066 .

Druckman, J. N. ( 2001 b). Using credible advice to overcome framing effects . Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 17(1), 62 - 82 .

Druckman, J. N. ( 2013 ). Public opinion: Stunted policy support . Nature Climate Change, 3(7), 617 .

Druckman, J. N. ( 2017 ). The crisis of politicization within and beyond science . Nature Human Behaviour, 1(9), 615 .

Druckman, J. N., Leeper, T. J., Slothuus, R. ( 2018 ). Motivated responses to political communications: Framing, party cues, and science information . In Lavine, H. G., Taber, C. S. (Eds.), The feeling, thinking citizen: Essays in honor of Milton Lodge (pp. 125 - 150 ). New York, NY : Routledge .

Druckman, J. N., Lupia, A. ( 2017 ). Using frames to make scientific communication effective . In Scheufele, D., Kahan, D. M., Jamieson, K. H. (Eds.), Handbook of the science of science communication (pp. 13 - 31 ). New York, NY : Oxford University Press .

Druckman, J. N., McGrath, M. C. ( 2019 ). The evidence for motivated reasoning in climate change preference formation . Nature Climate Change, 9, 111 - 119 .

Dunlap, R. E., McCright, A. M., Yarosh, J. H. ( 2016 ). The political divide on climate change: Partisan polarization widens in the US . Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 58(5), 4 - 23 .

Eagly, A. H., Chaiken, S. ( 1993 ). The psychology of attitudes. Fort Worth, TX : Harcourt Brace Jovanovich College .

Egan, P. J., Mullins, M. ( 2017 ). Climate change: US public opinion . Annual Review of Political Science, 20, 209 - 227 .

Ehret, P. J., Van Boven, L., Sherman, D. K. ( 2018 ). Partisan barriers to bipartisanship: Understanding climate policy polarization . Social Psychological and Personality Science, 9, 308 - 318 .

Feinberg, M., Willer, R. ( 2013 ). The moral roots of environmental attitudes . Psychological Science, 24(1), 56 - 62 .

Feldman, L., Hart, P. S. ( 2018 ). Is there any hope? How climate change news imagery and text influence audience emotions and support for climate mitigation policies . Risk Analysis, 38, 585 - 602 .

Feldman, L., Maibach, E. W., Roser-Renouf, C., Leiserowitz, A. ( 2012 ). Climate on cable: The nature and impact of global warming coverage on Fox News, CNN, and MSNBC . International Journal of Press/Politics, 17(1), 3 - 31 .

Gauchat, G. ( 2012 ). Politicization of science in the public sphere: A study of public trust in the United States, 1974 to 2010 . American Sociological Review, 77, 167 - 187 .

Goldberg, M., van der Linden, S., Leiserowitz, A., Maibach, E. ( 2019 ). Perceived social consensus can reduce ideological biases on climate change . Environment and Behavior. Advance online publication. doi:10.17863/CAM.37992

Goren, P., Federico, C. M., Kittilson, M. C. ( 2009 ). Source cues, partisan identities, and political value expression . American Journal of Political Science, 53, 805 - 820 .

Guber, D. L. ( 2017 ). Partisan cueing and polarization in public opinion about climate change . In Oxford research encyclopedia of climate science. doi:10.1093/acrefore/9780190228620.013.306

Hamilton, L. C. ( 2011 ). Education, politics and opinions about climate change evidence for interaction effects . Climatic Change, 104, 231 - 242 .

Hamilton, L. C. ( 2016 ). Public awareness of scientific consensus on climate . Sage Open. doi:10.1177/2158244016676296

Hart, P. S. ( 2011 ). One or many? The influence of episodic and thematic climate change frames on policy preferences and individual behavior change . Science Communication, 33, 28 - 51 .

Hart, P. S., Feldman, L. ( 2014 ). Threat without efficacy? Climate change on US network news . Science Communication, 36, 325 - 351 .

Hart, P. S., Feldman, L. ( 2016 ). The impact of climate change–related imagery and text on public opinion and behavior change . Science Communication, 38, 415 - 441 .

Hart, P. S., Feldman, L., Leiserowitz, A., Maibach, E. ( 2015 ). Extending the impacts of hostile media perceptions: Influences on discussion and opinion polarization in context of climate change . Science Communication, 37, 506 - 532 .

Hart, P. S., Nisbet, E. C. ( 2012 ). Boomerang effects in science communication: How motivated reasoning and identity cues amplify opinion polarization about climate mitigation policies . Communication Research, 39, 701 - 723 .

Hmielowski, J. D., Feldman, L., Myers, T. A., Leiserowitz, A., Maibach, E. ( 2014 ). An attack on science? Media use, trust in scientists, and perceptions of global warming . Public Understanding of Science, 23, 866 - 883 .

Hogg, M. A., Reid, S. A. ( 2006 ). Social identity, self-categorization, and the communication of group norms . Communication Theory, 16, 7 - 30 .

Huddy, L. ( 2001 ). From social to political identity: A critical examination of social identity theory . Political Psychology, 22, 127 - 156 .

Huddy, L., Mason, L., Aarøe, L. ( 2015 ). Expressive partisanship: Campaign involvement, political emotion, and partisan identity . American Political Science Review, 109, 1 - 17 .

Jost, J. T. ( 2018 ). Underestimating belief in climate change . Nature Climate Change, 8, 189 - 190 .

Jost, J. T., van der Linden, S., Panagopoulos, C., Hardin, C. D. ( 2018 ). Ideological asymmetries in conformity, desire for shared reality, and the spread of misinformation . Current Opinion in Psychology, 23, 77 - 83 .

Kahan, D. M. ( 2015 ). Climate-science communication and the measurement problem . Political Psychology, 36, 1 - 43 .

Kahan, D. M. ( 2016 ). The politically motivated reasoning paradigm, Part 1: What politically motivated reasoning is and how to measure it . In Scott, R. A., Kosslyn, S. M. (Eds.), Emerging trends in the social and behavioral sciences. New York, NY : Wiley . doi:10.1002/9781118900772.etrds0417

Kahan, D. M., Jenkins-Smith, H., Braman, D. ( 2011 ). Cultural cognition of scientific consensus . Journal of Risk Research, 14, 147 - 174 .

Kahan, D. M., Peters, E., Wittlin, M., Slovic, P., Ouellette, L. L., Braman, D., Mandel, G. ( 2012 ). The polarizing impact of science literacy and numeracy on perceived climate change risks . Nature Climate Change, 2, 732 - 735 .

Kahneman, D., Tversky, A. ( 1979 ). Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk . Econometrica, 47, 263 - 291 .

Kousser, T., Tranter, B. ( 2018 ). The influence of political leaders on climate change attitudes . Global Environmental Change, 50, 100 - 109 . doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.03.005.

Kunda, Z. ( 1990 ). The case for motivated reasoning . Psychological Bulletin, 108, 480 - 490 .

Leiserowitz, A. ( 2007 ). Communicating the risks of global warming: American risk perceptions, affective images, and interpretive communities . In Moser, S. C., Dilling, L. (Eds.), Creating a climate for change: Communicating climate change and facilitating social change (pp. 44 - 63 ). Cambridge, England : Cambridge University Press .

Leiserowitz, A., Maibach, E., Roser-Renouf, C., Rosenthal, S., Cutler, M., Kotcher, J. ( 2018 ). Climate change in the American mind: March 2018. New Haven, CT : Yale Program on Climate Change Communication .

Lelkes, Y., Malka, A., Bakker, B. N. ( 2018 ). An expressive utility account of partisan cue receptivity: Cognitive resources in the service of identity expression. Unpublished manuscript, Annenberg School for Communication, University of Pennsylvania . Retrieved from https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/dc57/456399c71dfb8ed13bc52bb65c0857987a0f.pdf

Lenz, G. S. ( 2012 ). Follow the leader? How voters respond to politicians’ policies and performance. Chicago, IL : University of Chicago Press .

Levin, I. P., Schneider, S. L., Gaeth, G. J. ( 1998 ). All frames are not created equal: A typology and critical analysis of framing effects . Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 76, 149 - 188 .

Lewandowsky, S., Gignac, G. E., Vaughan, S. ( 2013 ). The pivotal role of perceived scientific consensus in acceptance of science . Nature Climate Change, 3, 399 - 404 .

Lewandowsky, S., Oberauer, K., Gignac, G. E. ( 2013 ). NASA faked the moon landing—therefore, (climate) science is a hoax: An anatomy of the motivated rejection of science . Psychological Science, 24, 622 - 633 .

Li, N., Hilgard, J., Scheufele, D. A., Winneg, K. M., Jamieson, K. H. ( 2016 ). Cross-pressuring conservative Catholics? Effects of Pope Francis’ encyclical on the US public opinion on climate change . Climatic Change, 139, 367 - 380 .

Liu, H., Priest, S. ( 2009 ). Understanding public support for stem cell research: Media communication, interpersonal communication and trust in key actors . Public Understanding of Science, 18, 704 - 718 .

Lodge, M., Taber, C.S. ( 2013 ). The rationalizing voter. New York, NY : Cambridge University Press .

Lupia, A. ( 2013 ). Communicating science in politicized environments . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110 ( Suppl. 3 ), 14048 - 14054 .

Maibach, E. W., Leiserowitz, A., Roser-Renouf, C., Myers, T., Rosenthal, S., Feinberg, G. ( 2015 ). The Francis effect: How Pope Francis changed the conversation about global warming. New Haven, CT : Yale Program on Climate Change Communication .

Maibach, E. W., Nisbet, M., Baldwin, P., Akerlof, K., Diao, G. ( 2010 ). Reframing climate change as a public health issue: An exploratory study of public reactions . BMC Public Health, 10, 299 . doi:10.1186/1471-2458-10-299

Malka, A., Krosnick, J. A., Langer, G. ( 2009 ). The association of knowledge with concern about global warming: Trusted information sources shape public thinking . Risk Analysis: An International Journal, 29, 633 - 647 .

Malka, A., Lelkes, Y. ( 2010 ). More than ideology: Conservative–liberal identity and receptivity to political cues . Social Justice Research, 23, 156 - 188 .

McCright, A. M., Charters, M., Dentzman, K., Dietz, T. ( 2016 ). Examining the effectiveness of climate change frames in the face of a climate change denial counter-frame . Topics in Cognitive Science, 8(1), 76 - 97 .

McCright, A. M., Dentzman, K., Charters, M., Dietz, T. ( 2013 ). The influence of political ideology on trust in science . Environmental Research Letters, 8, 044029 .

McCright, A. M., Dunlap, R. E. ( 2011 ). The politicization of climate change and polarization in the American public’s views of global warming, 2001–2010 . Sociological Quarterly, 52, 155 - 194 .

Mildenberger, M., Tingley, D. ( 2017 ). Beliefs about climate beliefs: The importance of second-order opinions for climate politics . British Journal of Political Science, 1 - 29 . doi:10.1017/S0007123417000321

Miller, J. M., Saunders, K. L., Farhart, C. E. ( 2016 ). Conspiracy endorsement as motivated reasoning: The moderating roles of political knowledge and trust . American Journal of Political Science, 60, 824 - 844 .

Motta, M. ( 2018 ). The polarizing effect of the march for science on attitudes toward scientists . PS: Political Science & Politics, 51, 782 - 788 .

Mullinix, K. J., Leeper, T. J., Druckman, J. N., Freese, J. ( 2015 ). The generalizability of survey experiments . Journal of Experimental Political Science, 2, 109 - 138 .

Myers, T. A., Nisbet, M. C., Maibach, E. W., Leiserowitz, A. A. ( 2012 ). A public health frame arouses hopeful emotions about climate change . Climatic Change, 113, 1105 - 1112 .

Nisbet, E. C., Cooper, K. E., Garrett, R. K. ( 2015 ). The partisan brain: How dissonant science messages lead conservatives and liberals to (dis) trust science . Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 658(1), 36 - 66 .

Nisbet, M. C. ( 2009 ). Communicating climate change: Why frames matter for public engagement . Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 51(2), 12 - 23 .

Nisbet, M. C., Mooney, C. ( 2007 ). Policy forum: Framing science . Science, 316, 5821 - 5856 .

Nisbet, M. C., Myers, T. ( 2007 ). The polls—trends: Twenty years of public opinion about global warming . Public Opinion Quarterly, 71, 444 - 470 .

O’Keefe, D. J. ( 1990 ). Persuasion: Theory and research. Newbury Park, CA : Sage .

Oliver, J. E., Wood, T. J. ( 2014 ). Conspiracy theories and the paranoid style (s) of mass opinion . American Journal of Political Science, 58, 952 - 966 .

Petty, R. E., Cacioppo, J. T. ( 1986 ). The elaboration likelihood model of persuasion . In Communication and persuasion (pp. 1 - 24 ). New York, NY : Springer .

Priest, S. H. ( 2001 ). Misplaced faith: Communication variables as predictors of encouragement for biotechnology development . Science Communication, 23, 97 - 110 .

Prior, J., Partridge, E., Plant, R. ( 2014 ). We get the most information from the sources we trust least: Residents’ perceptions of risk communication on industrial contamination . Australasian Journal of Environmental Management, 21, 346 - 358 . doi:10.1080/14486563.2014.954011

Renn, O., Levine, D. ( 1991 ). Credibility and trust in risk communication . In Communicating risks to the public (pp. 175 - 217 ). Dordrecht, Netherlands : Springer .

Tversky, A., Kahneman, D. ( 1981 ). The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice . Science, 211, 453 - 458 .

Uscinski, J. E., Klofstad, C., Atkinson, M. D. ( 2016 ). What drives conspiratorial beliefs? The role of informational cues and predispositions . Political Research Quarterly, 69, 57 - 71 .

Uscinski, J. E., Parent, J. M. ( 2014 ). American conspiracy theories. Oxford, England : Oxford University Press .

Van Boven, L., Ehret, P. J., Sherman, D. K. ( 2018 ). Psychological barriers to bipartisan public support for climate policy . Perspectives on Psychological Science, 13, 492 - 507 .

van der Linden, S. ( 2015 ). The social-psychological determinants of climate change risk perceptions: Towards a comprehensive model . Journal of Environmental Psychology, 41, 112 - 124 .

van der Linden, S., Leiserowitz, A., Maibach, E. ( 2019 ). The gateway belief model: A large-scale replication . Journal of Environmental Psychology, 62, 49 - 58 doi:10.1016/j.jenvp.2019.01.009.

van der Linden, S., Leiserowitz, A., Rosenthal, S., Maibach, E. ( 2017 ). Inoculating the public against misinformation about climate change . Global Challenges, 1, 1 - 7 .

Villar, A., Krosnick, J. A. ( 2011 ). Global warming vs. climate change, taxes vs. prices: Does word choice matter? Climatic Change, 105, 1 - 12 .