Male circumcision needs to be seen as barbaric and unnecessary – just like female genital mutilation

Authored by independent.co.uk and submitted by Cuthate

The debate over male ritual circumcision – the surgical removal of the foreskin from the penis of a baby boy for religious and cultural reasons – is becoming more prominent each year. A BBC documentary broadcast this week provides further evidence that the tide is beginning to turn on the historic carte blanche afforded to infant circumcision.

The non-therapeutic alteration of children’s genitals is typically discussed in two separate ethical discourses: one for girls, in which such alteration is referred to as “female genital mutilation” (or FGM), and one for boys, in which it is usually referred to as “male circumcision”. The former is illegal in the UK and typically regarded as barbaric; the latter, benign or even “beneficial”.

But the similarities between the two practices are glaring. Both procedures vary in severity. Both involve painful and usually permanent surgery on a non-consenting child. Both are medically unnecessary. And both are risky.

We’ll tell you what’s true. You can form your own view. From 15p €0.18 $0.18 USD 0.27 a day, more exclusives, analysis and extras.

Just last week reports emerged of a one-month-old baby having to have his penis amputated in Egypt after it turned gangrenous following a circumcision. Earlier this year, two baby boys died in Italy after their genitals were cut for religious reasons. Circumcisions in the UK have also resulted in serious injury and deaths.

But even when carried out “successfully”, circumcisions involve the cutting away of erogenous tissue leading to a loss of penile sensitivity, inhibiting sexual pleasure. This alone should justify a shift in the way we think about this issue.

Shape Created with Sketch. UK news in pictures Show all 50 left Created with Sketch. right Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. UK news in pictures 1/50 23 July 2019 Boris Johnson holds his acceptance speech after he is announced as the new Conservative party leader. The former London mayor and foreign secretary was confirmed as the winner in the party contest to replace Theresa May as leader of the Conservative Party. He will also take up the post of Britain's prime minister on 24 July EPA 2/50 22 July 2019 New Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson addresses the audience onstage after she was named as Sir Vince Cable's successor. Swinson beat fellow candidate Ed Davey by 47,997 votes to 28,021 votes Getty 3/50 21 July 2019 Adam Peaty broke his own world record in the men's 100 metre breaststroke at the World Championships in Gwangju, South Korea. The 24-year-old smashed the previous record of 57.10 seconds he set at last year's European Championships to win in 56.88. In doing so, the Britain achieved one of his career goals of becoming the first man to break the 57-second barrier in the event Reuters 4/50 20 July 2019 London artist Helen Marshall's People's Moon project, a giant photographic mosaic shown at the exact hour 50 years ago that Apollo 11 landed the first people on the Moon, at Piccadilly Circus, London PA 5/50 19 July 2019 Players from Uganda and Malawi during their Netball World Cup match at the M&S Bank Arena, Liverpool PA 6/50 18 July 2019 Artist Steve Messam poses next to his monumental landscape artwork 'Hush' which hangs in the moors of Teesdale on July 18, 2019 in Barnard Castle, England. The outdoor installation is inspired by the geology, mining history and landscape of the area. The North Pennines AONB Partnership commissioned the installation which hangs over Bales Hush, a deep gauge in the terrain created when miners flushed the area with water to reveal the geological riches below. Hundreds of metres of recyclable saffron yellow fabric blow in the wind. Getty 7/50 17 July 2019 Buckingham Palace staff arrange the dining table, a copy of Queen Victoria's reign dessert table, as part of an exhibition at Buckingham Palace, in London. The exhibition marks the 200th anniversary of the birth of Queen Victoria AP 8/50 16 July 2019 The Inveraray pipe band parades through the town at the start of the Highland Games in Inverarary, Scotland Getty 9/50 15 July 2019 Extinction Rebellion Activists block roads near the Tron Clock tower in Glasgow Getty 10/50 14 July 2019 Serbia's Novak Djokovic raises the winner's trophy after beating Switzerland's Roger Federer during their men's singles final on day thirteen of the 2019 Wimbledon Championships at The All England Lawn Tennis Club AFP/Getty 11/50 13 July 2019 The referee counts Nathan Gorman out as Daniel Dubois looks on during the British Heavyweight Title fight between Daniel Dubois and Nathan Gorman at The O2 Arena in London Getty 12/50 12 July 2019 Giant Panda, Yang Guang, exploring his new home at Edinburgh Zoo after moving in last week RZSS/PA 13/50 11 July 2019 England's captain Eoin Morgan, left, celebrates with teammate Joe Root after winning their Cricket World Cup semi-final match against Australia at Edgbaston in Birmingham. The host nation blew away their rivals by 8 wickets with 107 balls remaining AP 14/50 10 July 2019 Andy Murray and Serena Williams talk as they play Bruno Soares and Nicole Melichar during their mixed doubles third round match of the Wimbledon Championships. The star-studded pair went out in three sets to the top seeds AFP/Getty 15/50 8 July 2019 Fifteen-year-old Cori "Coco" Gauff serves to Romania's Simona Halep in a women's singles match during day seven of the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London. The youngest woman to qualify for Wimbledon in the open era defeated Venus Williams in her opening match and made if through to week two. Halep ended the teenagers dream run at the tournament in their round 16 match, 6-3, 6-3 AP 16/50 7 July 2019 A competitor takes part in the Red Bull Soapbox Race in Alexandra Park, London. The soapbox race is an international event in which amateur drivers race homemade soapbox vehicles on a downhill course PA 17/50 6 July 2019 Members of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) community take part in the annual Pride Parade in London AFP/Getty Images 18/50 5 July 2019 Andy Murray fives mixed doubles partner Serena Williams at a practice session during day five of Wimbledon Getty Images 19/50 4 July 2019 Chelsea's newly appointed head coach Frank Lampard gives a thumbs up as he poses at Stamford Bridge. The Blues confirmed a dramatic return for one of the club's greatest ever players. He has signed a three-year contract with the Premier League club, where he spent 13 years and became the team's all-time leading scorer with 211 goals AFP/Getty 20/50 3 July 2019 A grey seal named after Sir David Attenborough is released back into the wild after months being treated at RSPCA East Winch Wildlife Centre in Norfolk after it was found with a plastic frisbee disc embedded in its neck PA 21/50 2 July 2019 The Kirby Estate in London is decorated with St George flags ahead of the Women's World Cup semi-final match between England and the USA PA 22/50 1 July 2019 People sleep as Glastonbury Festival 2019 comes to an end SWNS 23/50 30 June 2019 The crowd enjoys the atmosphere as Years & Years perform on the Pyramid Stage during day five of the Glastonbury Festival at Worthy Farm, Pilton on June 30, 2019 in Glastonbury, England Getty 24/50 29 June 2019 A couple make their way across the sand with their belongings as people enjoy the sunshine and hot weather on Bournemouth Beach in Dorset. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Saturday June 29, 2019 PA 25/50 28 June 2019 A lion-tailed macaque stays cool in the hot weather by eating frozen treats with fruit at Camperdown Wildlife Centre, Dundee Katielee Arrowsmith / SWNS 26/50 27 June 2019 A festival goer dance with LED hula hoops on the second day of Glastonbury Festival 2019 PA 27/50 26 June 2019 Festival goers warm up prior to the gates opening at 8am on the first day of Glastonbury 2019 Adam Gray / SWNS 28/50 25 June 2019 An early glimpse of this year's Glastonbury Festival is given in this picture taken by a local who glided over the site in their paramotor James Pearce / SWNS 29/50 24 June 2019 The interior roof of a Tesco shop collapses under the torrential rain in Stirling, Scotland on 24 June James Charity 30/50 23 June 2019 Steph Houghton celebrates with teammates after scoring England's first goal during the Women's World Cup round of 16 match against Cameroon at the Stade du Hainaut stadium in Valenciennes, France AP 31/50 22 June 2019 Pride marchers at a rally outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh PA 32/50 21 June 2019 The sun rises between the stones and over crowds at Stonehenge where people gather to celebrate the dawn of the longest day in the UK. The neolithic Wiltshire monument is built along the solstice alignment of the summer sunrise and the winter sunset. On the longest day of the year, the sun rises behind the Heel Stone, the ancient entrance to the Stone Circle, and rays of sunlight are channeled into the centre of the monument PA 33/50 20 June 2019 Frankie Dettori celebrates with the trophy after winning the 4.20 Gold Cup on Stradivarius as Queen Elizabeth looks on Action/Reuters 34/50 19 June 2019 Endangered Amur tiger cub Makari plays with a pinata which was given to him and brothers Dmitri and Czar as they celebrate their first birthday this week at Whipsnade Zoo in Dunstable PA 35/50 18 June 2019 Eoin Morgan celebrates his century with Joe Root during England's ICC Cricket World Cup match against Afghanistan at Old Trafford in Manchester. Morgan hit 17 sixes and set a new record in one-day international cricket, which saw his side win by 150 runs Getty 36/50 17 June 2019 Worcestershire County Cricket Club's New Road ground fully submerged by floodwater following heavy rainfall in the area. Worcestershire switched next week's County Championship home game with Sussex to Kidderminster due to the threat of flooding at the ground PA 37/50 16 June 2019 Dominic Raab (left) and Rory Stewart during the live television debate on Channel 4 for the candidates for leadership of the Conservative party, at the Here East studios in Stratford, east London PA 38/50 15 June 2019 Great Britain celebrate their first place on the podium during the Accenture World Triathlon Mixed Relay at Nottingham Embankment PA 39/50 14 June 2019 Mayor of London Sadiq Khan speaks at a service of remembrance at St Helens church, London, to mark the two-year anniversary of the Grenfell Tower block fire PA 40/50 13 June 2019 Community member Desi Cranenburgh attaches her latest homemade tribute near to the site of Grenfell Tower in London, a day before the second anniversary of the fire which killed 72 people Getty 41/50 12 June 2019 Boris Johnson during the launch of his campaign to become leader of the Conservative and Unionist Party and Prime Minister at the Royal Academy of Engineering in central London PA 42/50 11 June 2019 Strip club dancer Celia Lister protests with other demonstrators to oppose moves to close a branch of Spearmint Rhino in Sheffield. Dancers marched through the city centre after a row developed over whether to renew Spearmint Rhino's licence for the premises. The debate deepened after reports a video had been filmed by private investigators of sex acts taking place in the club PA 43/50 10 June 2019 A peregrine falcon chick calls out during ringing and data collection by RSPB expert handlers in the tower at Salisbury Cathedral. Four newly hatched birds of prey are nesting along with mum and dad on the South tower. PA 44/50 9 June 2019 England's forward Ellen White celebrates after scoring during the France 2019 Women's World Cup Group D football match between England and Scotland. White's goal was England's second of the match, which they went on to win 2-1 AFP/Getty 45/50 8 June 2019 Jason Roy celebrates his century with Joe Root. He went on to hit 153 as England scored their highest Cricket World Cup total of 386. The hosts beat Bangladesh by 106 runs to bounce back from defeat to Pakistan in their previous match Action/Reuters 46/50 7 June 2019 Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn celebrates with newly elected labour MP Lisa Forbes at Cathedral Square, Peterborough following her victory in the Peterborough by-election. The newly-formed Brexit Party lost out to Labour by 683 votes PA 47/50 6 June 2019 Veterans observe a two minute silence at the National Memorial Arboretum at Alrewas, in Staffordshire, for a service to mark the 75th anniversary of the D-Day landings PA 48/50 5 June 2019 French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Theresa May, Britain's Prince Charles, Queen Elizabeth II, President Donald Trump, first lady Melania Trump and Greek President Prokopis Pavlopoulos, front row from left, watch a fly past at the end of an event to mark the 75th anniversary of D-Day in Portsmouth AP 49/50 4 June 2019 Anti-Donald Trump protesters gather with a Trump baby blimp flying over Parliament Square for a protest against the US president's state visit to the UK EPA 50/50 3 June 2019 Queen Elizabeth II views a display of US items of the Royal collection with US President Donald Trump and US First Lady Melania Trump at Buckingham palace AFP/Getty

It can come with psychological problems, too. This year, a mother told her devastating story of how her 23-year-old son killed himself following the trauma he experienced following circumcision – a practice he felt should be known as "male genital mutilation". Alex Hardy's suicide prompted other men to speak out about their own experiences of circumcision.

The psychological effects are likely to be greatly under-reported. People who have experienced sexual harm are often reluctant to reveal it as societal dismissal or stigmatisation may compound the harm.

Defenders of male circumcision sometimes try to justify the practice by citing “health benefits”. Throughout history, male circumcision has been advocated as a pseudo-medical cure for a variety of ailments ranging from TB to epilepsy to warts to excessive masturbation.

But no national medical, paediatric, surgical or urological society in the world recommends routine circumcision of boys as a health intervention. In truth, circumcision is a solution in search of a problem. As the medical ethicist Brian Earp has pointed out, “A large proportion of the current medical literature purporting to show health benefits for male circumcision has been generated by doctors who were themselves circumcised at birth – often for religious reasons – and who have cultural, financial, or other interests in seeing the practice preserved.”

FGM is a violation of the human rights of girls. Non-therapeutic male circumcision is a violation of the rights of boys. The gendered double standard in the way the law deals with them needs to be addressed.

Our response to both forms of cutting should be to apply the principle of genital autonomy and bodily integrity to all children, irrespective of their sex. Circumcision before the age of consent deprives a boy of a body part that he would otherwise likely appreciate. Every child should enjoy the freedom to grow up with an intact body and to make their own choices about permanent bodily modifications. If they consent to their own non-therapeutic circumcision when they are old enough to do so, then fine. But let’s at least give them that choice.

Pro-cutting groups claim this is an issue of religious freedom. But too often, debates around religious freedom are framed solely by those who only really care about their own. Those narrowly focused on maximising their own freedoms can sometimes fail to recognise and consider how their right to manifest their beliefs tramples on the rights of others. The demand for religious freedom to be respected is often little more than a demand for the state to turn a blind eye to the violation of other's rights and freedoms when done in the name of religion.

But as a society we have a duty to balance competing freedoms and consider the rights of the child. Why should a parent’s religious freedom trump a child's right to religious freedom and bodily integrity?

Whilst you have the absolute right to your beliefs, you don't necessarily have the right to impose those beliefs on others – and you certainly shouldn't assume to have the right to impose them with a pair of scissors or a sharp knife on a non-consenting child.

Stephen Evans is the chief executive officer of the National Secular Society

Russian_Batman1 on July 23rd, 2019 at 23:44 UTC »

Russian guy here, circumcised at the age of 15. I did it under pressure from my father, as i felt i had no right to say “no”. I still remember the dread and terror of going to that surgery, and how much i cried for a few days beforehand.

Don’t do this to your kids. Let them decide it for themselves when they’re old enough and don’t fucking pressure them.

ratherimpractical on July 23rd, 2019 at 20:35 UTC »

Outright ban EU-wide, I say. If it's a religious thing, people can do it when they're 18 and can give informed consent.

Void_Ling on July 23rd, 2019 at 17:05 UTC »

Any non-medically required operation should be banned on kids.