FILE PHOTO: The building of the U.S. Supreme Court is pictured in Washington, U.S., March 18, 2019.
Monday’s ruling was in line with a 2015 decision in which the court rejected a challenge to Oklahoma’s method of execution by lethal injection.
In that case, the court held that inmates challenging a method of execution must come up with an alternative option that was less painful.
Bucklew failed to show that lethal gas could be “readily implemented” as required under Supreme Court precedent, the court ruled.
“Yet since then, he has managed to secure delay through lawsuit after lawsuit,” Gorsuch wrote, echoing a view often expressed by death penalty advocates.
When death row inmates seek last-minute stays of execution, courts should individual cases on their merits, Sotomayor said.
Other recent cases also illustrated the court’s differences over the death penalty. »